wogma rating: Add to 'must watch' list (?)
It's a very warm film and can make you nostalgic. It brings out irony that is part of everyday life. It comments on a blistering issue in society, but it doesn't let the issue take over the film. But it is also very slow and predictable.Read more
A trailer left me feeling warm towards the protagonist Stanley. He is endearing and he is real.
As soon as you watch it you somehow remember Taare Zameen Par. And but of course, it is the sole-proprietorship of Taare Zameen Par's creative director. Remember there was this huge controversy about who the real director of the film was? I loved the film, so much so that I didn't even realize its specific flaws till I saw it for the fourth and fifth times. Which is when I realized how wonderfully beautiful the first half of the film is and how blatantly the actor, Aamir Khan takes the film away from the character, Ishaan Awasthi. And that's when I realized that it almost looks like the first and second halves were directed by different people.
Somehow Stanley Ka Dabba gives the feel that it will be our chance to see how it'd be if Taare Zameen Par was directed by one person, and hopefully Amole Gupte directed the first half. Sure, the low budgets and the lack of marketing suave will be conspicuous by their absence. But a good film, with strong and relatable characters don't need anything else.
That brings me to my worry. Amole Gupte plays a teacher in the film which comes across as caricatured and rather slapsticky. I want fresh and real, not another round of slaps and food-dripping-out-of-mouth kind of humor. For that we have our Priyadarshans and David Dhawans and Bazmees.
Well, whatever the case, the one and only man to take blame or credit will be Amole Gupte because he's the producer, director, writer, actor and lyricist of the film. And hopefully the the trailer is exactly what it should be - a peek into how charming the characters are. Certainly looking forward to this one!
Ps. There weren't too many music reviews around at the time this article was written.
- meeta, a part of the audience
Stanley ka Dabba, the title by itself warmed me up to the film. I used to be that lazy one in school who'd never get her "tiffin box". And this is after my little sister would pack it early in the morning. I don't know, my own dabba just never was fascinating enough. Years later, as I watch Stanley ka Dabba, I realize maybe it was a 'bonding' thing for me. Many friends made over shared parathas and buscuits. Sure, Stanley's reason for not bringing food for himself is as far from laziness as it could be, but the fact that he didn’t have his meal with him brought the same result. Many friends and lovely memories. Despite this fondness though, Stanley ka Dabba seemed slow, predictable and repetitive in its 95 minute duration.
Stanley ka Dabba's promo also makes you believe that there is going to be something really deep in the film that will take repeated viewings to deconstruct. It raises a question about Stanley's background that remains unanswered till the last ten minutes of the film. By then, you have pretty much made up your own sad story about his family and probable life-style situation. And the climax gives you exactly that. In that sense, the film is unpredictable, right? You were expecting something more, something beyond the superficial but didn't get it.
But who says every film has to have a zen moment of realization? For what it is, Stanley ka Dabba is perfectly enjoyable because of its simplicity and how relatable it is. A science teacher who constantly asks you to stick to the norms, a unreasonable Hindi teacher who insists that the Goddess of knowledge will oblige only if you use the right hand. Stanley ka Dabba is all about simple things like these and the fact that every student who has come out of a traditional Indian school environment will find something to smile at.
And if you can't identify with the events of the film, there's always Stanley to smile with. Partho plays the charming Stanley, a master story-teller, who has a very strong self-esteem. In fact, all the kids in the film are perfect in their roles - almost as if they aren't acting at all.
The kids in the theater around me seemed to love every minute they spent with Stanley. They didn't seem to mind the slow pace or the repetition. It didn't matter that there seemed to be no valid reason for the angst and resolution thereof between Stanley and his Hindi teacher. Nor did they care that the climax does nothing outside the box. The protagonist is the hero and has a story that tugs the right strings for that lumpy throat.
I'm really curious how the film is going to be liked at film festivals both Indian and international. The context is very Indian. In fact, it is documentation of the education system and the culture revolving in schools in India. Fortunately, the "new-age" schools might be changing the teacher-facing experience. Unfortunately though it might be changing the dabba experience too.
- meeta, a part of the audience
External reviews for this movie are not available
vkv_iyer: Had a wonderful weekend..Saw Amol Gupte's 'Stanley Ka Dabba'..It was an exhilarating ride...Just too brilliant..Hats off to Amol..
vivekranjit: Here's what I thought about the beautiful movie #StanleyKaDabba - http://vivekranjit.blogspot.com/2011/05/stanley-ka-dabba-is-delicious.html
vivekbbhatia: Stanley Ka Dabba is such a beautiful film. Thoughtful and endearing it makes you cry and smile at the same time. Partho is a find.
vb779: Stanley ka dabba takes you back to your school days. Awesome movie. Must watch
varunwrites: The beauty of stanley ka dabba lies in the fact that there is no story just an incident
varungupte: Heard great things about Stanley Ka Dabba, so finally Amol Gupte gets his due
v1pul: Stanley ka Dabba - Fantastic, sweet little story with a heart in the rite place. Strongly recommended. If psbl watch with school friends :)
UrbanChick01: 'Stanley ka Dabba' is a must-watch! :D
tweet_kkkumar: Stanley ka dabba .. Go watch it if you still have not
tehriravi: Stanley ka dabba what a nice movie for kids. Grt work done
tanmayved: What a perfect weekend..Played Cricket for a full saturday then City wins the FA Cup then Stanley ka Dabba turns to be an absolute beauty..
taheena: Stanley Ka Dabba (Movie Review): A sparkling gem of a film, if ever there was one, Stanley Ka Dabba is the sort of rar http://feedproxy.google.com/~r/BankOfEntertainmentUnlimited/~3/q0hhPF9krP4/stanley-ka-dabba-movie-review.html
Swethlana: stanley ka dabba is juz superb....plz go watch da movie..itz touching da hearrt.....
swatidwivedi: Watch watch watch Stanley Ka Dabba :) It is cute and sensitive and moving at the same time!
sushantbhansali: Stanley ka dabba - no story but good fun, strong message and crowded thatre after a long time
SureshM_: Looking for something fat-free, sugar-free, light yet filling on the menu? Then take a bite from 'Stanley Ka Dabba'.
sundeepkishan: Stanley ka Dabba- I m hungry 4 more,Partho rocks,mindblowing BG score, @divyadutta25 was at her prettiest best,a Standing ovation 2 Mr.Amole
sumanthhs: Stanley ka dabba - very moving story, honest attempt to get the point across
Story_Tiller: Why Stanley Ka Dabba is as tasty and healthy as you'd like it to be - http://mayurica.blogspot.com/2011/05/stanley-ka-dabba-is-as-tasty-and_16.html?spref=tw As always, read, comment and repost :)
SRastogi84: STANLEY KA DABBA - Saw it today and cant get rid of the lump in my throat. Simple, touching and yes A MUST WATCH!
SocialPaparazzi: kal dekha...i was speechless. Must watch hai! @kalamwalibai @SocialPaparazzi mat.. Stanley ka dabba dekh.. 'tis nice
smritimiddha: watched Stanley ka Dabba over the weekend.... nice movie
smartdipu: Watched Stanley ka dabba and really liked it!! 4 stars :)
singh_dr: +1 RT @RohanDasgupta STANLEY KA DABBA is an amazing movie. Amol Gupte has pulled off a masterpiece here. It's a #MustWatch. #MyRating 4/5.
shruti_ravi: Stanley Ka Dabba?Charming film,really.Ok industry,you did your one nice thing in manure lot for a year thing.Rejoice.
shashanktodkar: Stanley Ka #Dabba #review: Simple, soulful, stylish
shamitasingha: Stanley ka dabba makes u sooo hungry!! Excellent background score!
sameer_s: stanley ka dabba - inginious
ronK30: Stanley Ka Dabba is such a beautiful film. Thoughtful and endearing it makes you cry and smile at the same time.
rohandasgupta: #MyReview: STANLEY KA DABBA is an amazing movie. Amol Gupte has pulled off a masterpiece here. It's a #MustWatch. #MyRating 4/5.
ratnakars: stanley ka dabba - a movie from a creative person - amol gupte - from the heart - don't expect a normal hindi movie
ranjanaeaswar: Stanley Ka Dabba did to me what Taare Zameen Par couldn't remotely come close to doing. It made me cry!
ramare: Saw Stanley ka Dabba too. Worth seeing once. And somehow made me realize I'm different frm the guy who saw TZP. No idea how, jus' feel it.
rakeshupar: Stanley ka dabba very good film ☺
rahibsiddiqui: ' Stanley ka dabba' must watch. Indeed a simple story wid a big heart.
Quirkylogic: Stanley ka Dabba: Poignant in its simplicity. Well done Amol Gupte.
proximoron: And i saw Stanley Ka Dabba today. Made me miss the school days all over again. Nice movie. Worth a watch.
programados: ★★★★★ Stanley ka dabba: A lunchbox full of delicious delights - Deccan Chronicle http://news.google.com/news/url?sa=t&fd=R&usg=AFQjCNFC5_ERITgHwekliZocWodvL4BwwA&url=http://www.deccanchronicle.com/channels/showbiz/bollywood/stanley-ka-dabba-lunchbox-full-delicious-delights-739 #cincoestrellas
Priraman: Stanley ka dabba - worth a watch
pmandrek: 'Stanley Ka Dabba' is a cute film with a strong message about child labor. The tiffin gang acted really well @stanleykatweets
parikshit_d: 'stanley ka dabba' a truly fascinating,straight from the heart,thoughtful piece of cinematic work...thanks Amol gupte and co..u made my day
pandyasheetal: Saw..stanley ka dabba..what a film.. Awesome.. All shud go and watch it.
nowme_datta: Stanley Ka Dabba is a sweet film. A really natural cast of actors and uncluttered languid storytelling. Not mawkish.
nivi15: Stanley ka Dabba...endearing, spontaneous, intense n well-crafted.Took me bk to the school days!:-)
nikkupikku: Stanley ka dabba.. Nice.. Adorable movie.. N Partho aka stanley ws superb! :)
nikhilnk: Watched Stanley Ka Dabba over the weekend. A very sincere attempt no doubt, but honestly an ok movie to watch. Still, go for it!
nehamaini: Don't miss Stanley Ka Dabba. I *will* judge you if you decide on Fast and Furious instead. #movies #love
neetakolhatkar: Stanley ka dabba!! Luuuuuuuuv it..thx amol guptey
MystiqueWanderr: saw stanley ka dabba...am glad i did...had good co. too...nice evening to sum it up i say
moviezadda: a very good plot that delves deep into a child’s life and portrays it well on screen - Stanley ka dabba
Mitafashi: A+ for Stanley Ka Dabba
meetSidd: saw Stanley ka dabba .. sweet movie ..if u r expecting a wholesome entertainer this in not the one ..but a cute nd heartwarming movie ..
MayankBhardwaj9: Stanley Ka Dabba is simply superb. No doubt, highly recommended.
maulik_b: Stanley ka dabba is brilliant sensitive & simple cinema, the way innocence of children has been captured is remarkable! Kudos Mr. Gupte!
manuptwits: Stanley ka Dabba reminds me of a wonderful chapter from school in Marathi called Shrinivas panse che angaan.... Sensitive and touching...
Mandipaksandhu: stanley ka dabba is a great film
mandeepkapoor24: saw stanley ka dabba yesterday excellent movie by amole gupte but i still think he should act more in movies besides he is a good director
m_SaiK: did i say about "STANLEY KA DABBA" yet... brilliant amol gupte movie. i say one of the best hindi movie this year... must watch dont miss it
krixnetworks: Review Stanley Ka Dabba is a marvellous debut: Not so for Babubhai Verma, who reveres not and… http://feeds.feedburner.com/~r/klixindia/~3/Vh0PpS38OgY/?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=twitter&utm_campaign=krixnetworks
KoolRitam: Stanley ka Dabba is a definitely one time dekhho-- reservoir thats takes you back to school day memories !!!
Kniikhil: Stanley ka dabba (4/5) just 1hr35mins a vry simple stories awesomely made n well acted by Mr Amole Gupte n the child artist. must c, i say.
kavitaalve1: Stanley ka dabba..fab..amazing..took me straight to my school days...vry cute perfomances by all...
kartikeyasaran: Stanley ka dabba... Excellent acting, and the end keeps you vying for more.
Kantaap: Stanley ka dabba was darned cute.
iSiddharthdesai: Stanley ka dabba..!!!! what a beutiful film.. hats off amol gupte.. #mastermind #masterclass.. and parthos performance... #extremetalent
isealedmylove: Stanley ka dabba ..... a must watch :)
HrithikIsShit: its very good . RT @mysticalreticen: @devika_g hahahahaa.. heard Amol stanley ka dabba is gud!!
helina_vora: Stanley ka Dabba 5 stars :D ... amazing movie .. and superb acting by all
GodrejAppliance: The movie 'Stanley ka Dabba' makes one go back to fond memories of one's days in #school. How were your school days and school teachers?
garganirudh: stanley ka dabba is another example of talented indian kids and directors that can that hit six on the last ball
fallon_sav: wnt out with frnds aft such a long and saw 'stanley ka dabba' a gud movie.............. :)
dubey_gaurav: For all dose who missn d school tim stanley ka dabba is for u all
dragonette18: Good evening #Twitterheads . Just came back from a thought provoking and sensational movie - Stanley ka Dabba But first the news !
dips1980: Back from 'Stanley ka dabba'.Really a lill movie with a big heart.
Dipilicious: absolutely RT @UrbanChick01: 'Stanley ka Dabba' is a must-watch! :D
DeskFabregas: Stanley ka Dabba - good movie. watch it .
deepikins: Stanley ka dabba. Simple and touching movie. Catch it if you can.
dancervaidya: Stanley ka dabba is a good light watch !
daisyplumsong: i have went to see stanley ka dabba today morning. awesome movie. u have gt to see tht
cute_shanatic: Stanley ka dabba Spellbounding! and as @shahidkapoor a movie with a heart! A must watch :))) [Like it? http://www.likemytweets.com/tweet/70084841588264960#70084841588264960%23like ]
cssjockey: Watched Fast 5 and Stanley Ka Dabba both movies are awesome!! Day well spent ;)
cibi121: Watched "Stanley Ka Dabba" a great watch..Hats Off Amole Gupte Watta Actor and nw a Director..#StanleyKaDabba
ChantelleCabral: Watched "Stanley Ka Dabba".. I smiled, I laughed, I cried. Anyone with a soul can relate to it. Heartfelt! #mustwatch #win
chandniwadhwa: 'Stanley Ka Dabba'-A beautiful story,very well enacted and portrayed!Pure Good Cinema..Go watch it!! :-)
bruceruless: Watched 'Stanley ka dabba' today.. Please watch it people... A heart warming message for all of us #Epic #FTW
bongubharat: Stanley ka Dabba was awesome - A must watch !!
bombaybookworm: Stanley ka dabba was such a perfect morning treat. what a waste to end the film with ronald Mcdonald
bobin_james: Stanley ka Dabba. Beautifully made. Don't miss it.
bhavinvora: Stanley ka Dabba. Heartwarming. Must Watch!
bhatiavinita: Watched 'Stanley ka dabba'. What a poignant movie.
BCSutta: Stanley ka Dabba is the second best thing that happened this weekend... 1st was DMK ki batti gul.
ashinvi: Strongly recommend everyone to watch "Stanley ka Dabba". A fine story which leave you feeling nostalgic :)
anurag_mohan: Stanley ka Dabba is a nice film. 3/5. That kid was better than the Taare Zameen Par kid.
anshulgarg007: watched Stanley ka dabba......A little story with a BIG heart
anishasingh: liked Stanley ka Dabba. A simple, honest film. And Partho, the kid is simply brilliant!
anilkpai: Just saw stanley ka dabba... Amazing movie... tackled a very real and disturbing issue in a unique way.
andaleebwajid: Made up my mind..taking kids to watch Stanley ka dabba as soon as I can...am sure sabs will relate to it..esp as he refuses to take one too
AnayDalal: Saw Stanley Ka Dabba...Amazing movie..Poignant and excellent..Must see.
anandcj: Loved Stanley Ka Dabba. SImple, Sweet, So touching. Great work, Amol Gupte!
Ammywalia: Stanley ka dabba is an amazingly beautiful film after a long time.⁰A karara thappad from mr gupte to mr pseudo perfectionist!
alisha_thaman: Stanley ka dabba ...a nice movie...
aliceinandheri: Really enjoyed Stanley ka Dabba... there's something about the film.
ajitjbhat: Loved 'Stanley ka Dabba', thank you Mr.Gupte for the skill with which you handled the subject, simple story, well executed 1/2
abyaya_d: Watchd stanley ka dabba yestrday..awsum flm..wd big heart!
abir_sanyal: Do yourself a favor.. go & watch 'Stanley Ka Dabba'..a very touchy film,with no self-pity and wonderfully transports you to Class 4..
abhishekbalu: stanley ka dabba... the mastermind behind "tarein zameen par" does it again... AMOL GUPTE- take a bow
abhibusy: Watched Stanley Ka Dabba yesterday total #win
Aagan86: stanley ka dabba is so cute
_tarkeebein: 'Stanley Ka Dabba'-A beautiful story,very well enacted and portrayed!Pure Good Cinema..Go watch it !! :-)
_SleepLover: Stanley ka dabba.. :P :P RT @iChocolatea: So Fast and Furious Five or Ragini MMS?
tweetgyan: Stanley ka Dabba is a documentary. A good movie for children and also for people who prefer to watch realistic cinema. #movie #review
ravikirana: Watched 'Stanley ka dabba'... Experimental film. Good concept. Film could have been better.
PsycheDylan: Stanley ka Dabba was just okay. You won't miss much if you only watch the second half.
prasannakumars: Stanley ka dabba is not exemplary as projected by media, just an Avg. movie with it's heart in the right place..
GautamReady: Stanley Ka Dabba - for the message to reach a larger section of the society, the movie should have had more commercial elements
cornerd: Stanley ka Dabba is weird
blahssome: And oh also saw, Stanley Ka Dabba. Cute little movie. But fairly unremarkable. Wonder what the hype was all about.
Sampad: Watched Stanley ka Dabba today. I think its superhype which led me to the theaters. I dont think its a theater-watchable movie at all #fb
ruchikabajoria: Stanley ka dabba is actlyy a dabba.... wat has happnd to d muvee critics, 4.5 ratngs 2 it. ddnt lyk it... bt still sum kids wer reli cutee
roysrus: Stanley Ka Dabba: Wondering if anyone would repay me for the tickets. I doubt it. Don't blame them. Waste of a Monday night.
nehakanwar: Stanley ka dabba needed some food in it . Movie was in a loop !
khyatisha: saw ragini mms,stanley ka dabba and haunted....none was so good to watch...:( disappointed bt njoed anyhow.:)
ghaywan: Am I the only one not too pleased by Stanley Ka Dabba?
chemingineer: Halfway through Stanley Ka Dabba I was expecting a parable of sorts. Turned out into a maudlin tearjerker with a loud social message.
AnshulGupta_: Stanley Ka Dabba is a dabba movie! Thoroughly boring. Learning - caution with Word Of Mouth and general buzz #MovieReview #fb
abhishek_1983: Stanley ka Dabba is for art overs not for people like me who managed 0 in arts also. It does now have the Bang for me.
Want to Watch, by mazar : 5
Yay! Thumbs Up, by Best web hosting company : Really nice
Yay! Thumbs Up, by darrensy : 100
Yay! Thumbs Up, by Frases romanticas
Yay! Thumbs Up, by Gaurav Batla
Yay! Thumbs Up, by Limette
Yay! Thumbs Up, by Montu jain : 100
Yay! Thumbs Up, by rahul : 100
This page has additional observations, other than the ones noted in the main review.
4th-grader Stanley gets into his gluttonous-Hindi teacher for not bringing his lunch box.