wogma rating: Add to that never-watched 'To Watch' list (?)
It's awesome that a film with a non-glam lady actor in the lead was produced. It brings greater joy that the story is about an everyday girl and she doesn't have some high profile job or boyfriend/husband. Alas, all of this becomes "blah" before you know it. What could have been a celebration of all things woman might just make all women turning 30 into a laughing stock.Read more
This is a country where the first attack of arthritis symbolizes aging. We dismissed my mom's menopause as random irritability. Making a big deal out of 'turning 30' is considered, at best, much ado about nothing. That does not make the problems facing the chic-urban-turning-30 any less important. Yes, they have it all, and they want more. And proudly so; even if they have to fight for it. In that sense Turning 30!!! could have been a very important film. But it turns out to be a drab narrative. You wait for the spark and you are kept waiting.
I consider myself a part of the target audience, I'm city-bred, so what if I turned 30 a little while ago. I might not be as chic as her, but I have more than a friend or two who are like the women Turning 30!!! talks about. Yet Naina (Gul Panag) and her friends don't even remotely touch me. I'd have wanted to smile with their jokes, nod at their insights about love, life and everything that goes with it. I'd have loved to cry with them too, but I cringed after the first couple of times I saw Gul cry. There's only so much of a grown-up woman you can see crying, after all.
The much talked about, and rightly so, Sex and The City hangover is as dreary and superficially profound as the original (go ahead, shoot me for killing your stereotype about all women liking SATC!) And yet, it wouldn't have been such a bore if it weren't so repetitive.
Fortunately, the writer/director is very open about showing a woman's sexual urges. Hindi films have after all, always been too shy to express sensuality. That her lust goes hand-in-hand with how desperate her love gets is a slice-of-life for any woman in love - age no bar. I also liked the hand homosexuality is dealt. Right from how close friends initially react to their lesbian friend coming out to them to how the larger group reacts to how everyone comes to terms with it.
Naina's struggle at work too is something that kept me going. It felt like the writer had some insight into a woman's aspirations at work; her frustrations with the macho men in her industry; and her struggle in getting what is rightfully hers. But, that too goes bust with a sorrily written climax.
That's the story of the film's life. There were many things going right, but sooner or later, they go flat.
Like a woman who's in her 60s is likely to say, celebrating or whining about a 30th is a thing-to-do by women who have it all and know nothing of real suffering and pain at the hands of their men. And this pain is physical versus the 'literal pain in the ass that her ex-boyfriend was', Naina is heard complaining about. But, that's for the 60-year old to say. We 30-Pluses had our chance and blew it.
- meeta, a part of the audience
Thumbs up, Movie Talkies : ...In a long time after 'Dor', Gul Panag finally gets a role which she can sink her teeth into and truly relish. This is one such role and the actress lives it perfectly.... full review
So-So, by Vikramjit Singh, Desi Martini : ...Full credit to the director(Alankrita Srivastava) and Gul for keeping it real and not making the crying too melodramatic. Although Gul Panag's narrative tends to get monotonous and bores you in places. Having said that, I can't think of another actress who could've essayed it better.... full review
So-So, by Deepa Deosthalee, Film Impressions : ...Turning 30 tries to give them the light-hearted treatment, but it needed to be much sharper to make the trials of a modern single woman evocative. Having said that, the broad strokes don't take away the fact that such women do exist and that their stories are just as relevant.... full review
Thumbs down, by Naresh Deoshi, Apun Ka Choice : ... The humour in the film stays strictly sophomoric, and indeed, the angst and anxiety of the film’s nerve-wrecked heroine begins to look bloated as she runs pillar to post, parlours to spas, not knowing what she wants. ... full review
Thumbs down, by Roshni Mulchandani, Bolly Spice : ...Really, in this day and age, turning 30 is hardly a big deal especially since 40 is considered the new 30. And that said, another major flaw with the film is that it is predominantly in English which ultimately limits the audiences it will attract... full review
Thumbs down, by Taran Adarsh, Bollywood Hungama : ...The smart usage of humour in the narrative, in the first hour specifically, makes it all the more compelling....Alankrita's writing lacks the consistency of the first half in its post-interval portions... full review
Thumbs down, by Gautam Chintamani, Buzz in Town : ...Instead Naina’s journey of finding herself is so fraught with utter absurdity that one wonders whatever made seemingly intelligent women like Gul Panag and Tillotama Shome agree to something like this? ... full review
Thumbs down, by Deepa Gahlot, Film Impressions : ...Naina is a bore -- whiny and clingy to boot. The nth time she goes “uh-uh-uh” and makes a sobby face, you want to throw something at the screen. Her predicament is as superficial as the solution -- writing a book!... full review
Thumbs down, by Sukanya Venkatraghavan, Filmfare : ...This is one film that’s screaming itself hoarse, lying on the floor throwing a tantrum saying, “I’m cool chick flick. Can’t you see? I’m a cool, cool chick flick.” Therein lies the tragedy.... full review
Thumbs down, by Shubhra Gupta, indian express : ...And the perky Gul Panag is the perfect choice to play a girl like that, whom one can bump into and recognize, not some illusory size zero female whose only job is to act as a clothes hanger for demented designers. ... full review
Thumbs down, by Udita Jhunjhunwala, Live Mint : ...lack of energy, pace or tangible storyline and stiff writing which, when translated into English dialogues, sounds like scripted speeches... full review
Thumbs down, by Minty Tejpal, Mumbai Mirror : ...The spunky Gul Panag manfully does a "sagging boob" scene in front of the mirror in a ladies loo, but that still can't lift the film enough. ... full review
Thumbs down, by Raja Sen, Rediff : ...A film can't be both empowering and embarrassing -- and here the latter is painfully predominant. The problems the characters face might well be real; the film, however, is anything but. ... full review
zainabjabri: Turning 30... Awesome movie.. Go n watch
XzanderCage: Watched turning 30 .... Yesterday ... The movie was good ... But the second half was a bit too long to handle ....
Vishalanam: Turning 30.. Too realistic to be just a movie and yet with Happy Ending. I liked it.. Go watch...
vipulsatya: Turning 30 is a brilliant movie. A must watch. Worth every second. Simple subtle and brilliant acting by @gulpanag :) #10on10
uday_1991: I jst watched "turning 30", i lyk mvie
togetherinlife: Turning 30...great movie & then a gr8 time in Hard rock cafe.
thebongbabe: My take on Turning 30: Sexy, witty, smart and true to life!
sujayray: Best scene of Turning 30 was when @gulpanag was driving the RE Thunderbird, and best dialogue when Purab said "I can sink into her dimples"
ShutterCrazy: I did like #Turning 30. All the actors were great! Very real, didn't revolve around a hero! But I don't think 1/2
samirmansuri: gul u look really best on bike!!!!! ur turning 30 rocks,hop see u more like that...
rohitbio2007: Turning 30!! Nice movie
ravikapoor: Turning 30: It's about today's urban woman, her struggles & how she overcomes 'em. Absolutely loved @gulpanag's slapstick humor! #pass
rahulnanda86: Turning 30 in theatres today!! Do what it!! I loved it :)
piyal_mukherjee: Watched Gul Panag's rebounds on 'Turning 30' - Agree tht its more of a Chick Flick, but I personally liked the movie... Good one!
phalange_chips: had a really nice night! #watched Turning 30, had Subway Chicken Salad for dinner and to keep myself warm got me a #Costa Coffee :D :)
pallavikaa: My take on 'Turning 30': Not my type of movie but certainly recommended for Gul Panag fans, myself included. her career best: Dor, Manorama.
Nidhik20: In other news .. Just watched Turning 30 .. n trust me @gulpanag is just wowwww in d movie!!She hs acted so damn well .. Deserves an award.
musingsman: Battery dead last night..beginning the day about "Turning 30"...well done @gulpanag Paisa Wasool..wish more such realistic films wr made
Mr_Twirt: Turning 30 jus took me by surprise. The best thing I cud hav done this sunday :D @gulpanag u rock. 2nd movie in a row and u want me craving!
missmalini: Nice work @gulpanag @PurabKohli! Totally enjoyed Turning 30. Also the soundtrack is surprisingly good :)
lovableaarti: turning 30 good realistic muvi!
KadwaDhatura: Just watched 'turning 30.'@gulpanag again made me fall I'n love with her once again. Stoled all the accolades. #win
Jhunjhunwala: My weekend has started well.I've seen 2 awesome movies - @gulpanag 's Turning 30 and Yamla Pagla Deewana.Both Rock.
IamDeepikaRM: "@MissMalini: @Purab_Kohli I loved Turning 30!" Me too.. But I felt purab was very under used.. Looked sooper hot though!!!
HindiPoet: Turning 30 is awesome Movie .. a must watch .. GUL is best at act :) @gulpanag
hifiab: turning 30, a classical act, made 4 classes, but will fail to deliver commercially
awtaney: Turning 30: realistic screenplay.
arpanak10: Turning 30! is a good movie to watch :-)
anandpar: Turning 30... A tad pretentious maybe, but eminently watchable...
Amit_J: Turning 30 is a wonderful movie... It's a must watch #movie.
Abinash03111992: Luv d fact dt our cinema's evolving!With films lyk turning 30 actresses r also gett'g meaty roles! Viewer get 2 see sumth'g new! @gulpanag
aakanshasethi: Turning thirty is awesome! Must watch
shadanmd: Turning 30 is a decent movie..but didnt excite me much..as i hve already dealth with d idea at extent long back..bt the mvie will hve takers
PillaiMK: Somewhere down the second half, the script does slip into cliches and the phobia of turning 30 gets a bit exaggerated.
neenzin: Turning 30, poorly directed yet fun to watch! Loosely tries to adapt the carrie-big relationship.
vodkaholic: While the world goes gaga over Golden Globes, here's my review of Turning 30: Terribly disappointing. Second half was better. Purab is HAWT.
vishalmundra04: Huh...turning 30 seems to be a disaster...some cheap humor...all in all waste of time.
vidya83: If you cringe every time someone cries in a film, it must be bad. #Turning 30
veryvitriolic: Turning 30 is a monumental disaster. The definitive proof that being a stud girl on twitter doesn't add up to shit
tishya_khillare: Turning 30 was all bout Gul Panag and her clinging on to Rishabh. What an #EpicFail portrayal of an independent thinking Indian woman.
SudhishKamath: Turning 30: The writing! Fuck. The writing! Never thought a day would come when I would call Aisha a classic. Feel really bad for Gul 3.5/10
spotlessmind27: am really really sorry @gulpanag ...expected loads out out turning 30, super let down :(
sauravbhanot: Turning 30 was very bad ! Hated it!
saurabhtyagi: turning@30-a B grade Indian version of SATC..full of clitches abt urban Indian single woman..the intention was rite but the execution sucks!
nishioswal: Turning 30...Prakash Jha, after making some critically acclaimed n award winning films, something filthy like this is just unacceptable..
nabilazaidi: Bollywood should take my advice rather seriously - GIVE UP ON CHICK FLICKS... U CAN NOT MAKE EM! Aisha! Turning 30! #wtf
mugdhakalra: Saw one of the worst films ever 'turning 30'. What a disaster!!!
kranium256: Turning 30 IS THE SADDEST MOVIE OF ALL TIME!! AARRRGGGHHH!! It's got inconsistent acting and a whole bunch of things gone wrong. Argh.
iprasadpatkar: Trust me Turning 30 isn't as astoundingly painful as the film
Bhadauriya18: Turning 30 must be a nightmare. But I'm sure it isn't as agonizingly painful as the film.
aneebunee: Saw Turning 30. Went in with no expectations & still came out disappointed. Story was ok. What happened with the dialogues, styling, acting?
No readers have rated this movie yet.
This page has additional observations, other than the ones noted in the main review.