wogma rating: Watch but no rush (?)
An obviously over-simplified account of an extremely engaging real-life event. The real-life bit is what keeps you glued despite tacky execution.Read more
It was a unique experience, watching Parmanu – The Story of Pokhran. I don’t think I have ever enjoyed a film for its basic content that had tacky production values, weird dramatisation, and workable if not awful performances. It is indeed because reality is stranger than fiction.
mediocre performances don’t come in the way of keeping you engaged
It is sheer madness – conceiving secret nuclear bomb testing while avoiding omnipresent US satellite surveillance. And they actually executed it! The methods described in the movie must just be a scratch on what actually happened. I assume the gaping holes in the story are owing to national security requirements. But the details they have in the movie are enough for you to sit up in awe, especially for someone like me who knew very little about the actual operation.
It is almost as if the makers knew exactly how gripping the basic story is – only that could explain the little effort put in the screenplay. It feels like it was written down based on a few interviews and then were added the layered frills of drama, patriotism, song, emotion, and so on. It is also almost as if the makers knew exactly how much faith they wanted to have in the audience. Nothing else can explain all the dramatization, over-written dialogue, the typical thriller elements such as pulsating count downs and expected twists, and oh the songs. In that sense, Parmanu does come across as a wasted opportunity.
The performances just about do. Fortunately, not much acting is called for in a thriller usually, so mediocre performances don’t come in the way of keeping you engaged. In fact, Boman Irani is caught doing one of his over-acting acts. Even so, Anuja Sathe stands out in one scene and it ends right about when she was going to give way to histrionics.
Interestingly, while watching that scene I became even more aware of how much they must have left out. Like Raazi, we would have easily dismissed Parmanu as a ludicrous figment of imagination and the situations as impossible, were it not a piece of real life.
It is indeed nice to see producers, directors, and actors take on subjects that are controversial and non-commercial. This bravery needs appreciation. Now, we need them to go the long haul and avoid commercial traps that make them add length through songs and redundant drama, just because. When the actual operation was so thrilling, the filmy drama is quite unnecessary.
- meeta, a part of the audience
Thumbs up, Bollywood Hungama : ...On the whole, PARMANU – THE STORY OF POKHRAN is an excellent saga that has a big chance of working at the box office despite the low buzz. The patriotic fervor and simple, effective narration works big time. Recommended! ... full review
Thumbs up, by Devansh Sharma, Filmfare : ...The film does have minor flaws and loose ends but you kind of gloss over them because of its emotional impact. At the end of the day, you feel proud of the achievements of the nation’s scientists, of our army. India really shone during the time and you want to hold on to that hope, however fragile it may be, that we can achieve wonders if we come together as a nation... ... full review
Thumbs up, by NILESH RAMCHANDANI, Kia Gia : ...On the whole, 'Parmanu' is the thriller Bollywood needs. It keeps you entertained throughout, along with enlightening the facts about an epic tale which was still under wraps. John Abraham is a winner; a must-watch! ... full review
Thumbs up, by Umesh Punwani, koimoi : ...All said and done, some movies serve more than just entertainment and Parmanu provides an experience that will linger in your soul for a long time post you leave the cinema hall. Don’t watch this for anyone, watch it for your country. ... full review
Thumbs up, by Rachit Gupta, Times of India : ...What ‘Parmanu’ lacks in detail and authenticity, it makes up with emotions and a sense of national pride. The narrative isn’t explosive but it does have the dramatic moments to keep the viewer engaged. Thrills, suspense, drama, a little bit of humour, as well as a solid comment on India’s soldiers – this movie, largely has all the tricks to please even a discerning audience. ... full review
So-So, by Bobby Sing, Bobby Talks Cinema.com : ...On a concluding note, do watch it and feel proud for the nation too, but along with remembering the fact that the Nuclear Power (as bombs) actually denotes destruction of the entire world and is not any positive creative construction if studied in the real sense. ... full review
So-So, by Hiren Kotwani, DNA : ...Parmanu, that simplifies an important chapter in the history of Independent India, makes an interesting watch without resorting to any jingoism. The climax evokes a sense of pride about India becoming a global power. ... full review
So-So, by Johnson Thomas, Free Press Journal : ...Abhishek Sharma and team don’t bother to dig deep. They appear to be satisfied generating febrile jingoistic fervour through a largely superficial and entirely fake orchestration of events. Pokhran may have been an effort worth immortalising on screen, but this skewed attempt is clearly not the one to bring that about! ... full review
So-So, by T J Reddyfull, fullhyd.com : ...To its detriment, the movie never builds on its strengths in a convincing fashion. As we've established by now, it has its positive moments (and that one shot of blast going off is genuinely mesmerising), but a genuinely spell-binding film fires positives from all cylinders, simultaneously. Parmanu, however, is a textbook example of the parts being better than the whole. ... full review
So-So, by Manjusha Radhakrishnan, Gulf News : ...But the dizzying sense of urgency that makes a film thrilling is missing here. There are no nail-biting finishes or adrenaline-charged situations that would have sky-rocked Parmanu to stratospheric limits. While the premise is intriguing, the film doesn’t blow your mind away. Watch this if you want superficial knowledge about what went down as India aggressively joined the nuclear arms race. ... full review
So-So, by Rohit Vats, Hindustan Times : ...John Abraham’s deadpan expressions are a hindrance but he somehow manages to hold his ground. Other actors follow his footsteps. It’s the writing that saves the day for Abraham and Parmanu. ... full review
So-So, by Suhani Singh, india today : ...Parmanu: The Story of Pokhran will especially appease fans of events like the surgical strike and those who like India winning at all costs even if it occasionally comes across a tad foolish.... full review
So-So, by NARENDRA GUPTA, Kia Gia : ...The characters of all the secondary artists are not developed properly. Sachin-Jigar fail to deliver a single hit number. It is strictly a one-time watch. ... full review
So-So, Masala : ...Despite resorting to some very obvious tricks, Parmanu: The Story of Pokhran remains noble in its intention of telling a historic tale that made every Indian proud. It's a good one time watch. ... full review
So-So, by Mayank Shekhar, MiD DAY : ...Really? Because they tested a bomb, and the Americans didn't know about it? And Pakistan conducted a series of similar tests in the same month? So frickin' what? To be fair to the film though, which only comes alive in the final half-hour, it doesn't exactly test your patience. That's saying a lot, even if its terribly militarised version of patriotism/jingoism isn't exactly your scene. ... full review
So-So, by Kunal Guha, Mumbai Mirror : ...Director Abhishek Sharma had a compelling story which could’ve rendered a thrilling watch, if only he could’ve focussed on telling it with some conviction. Perhaps throwing in a few more turns in the script and cumulatively making the inevitable seem bleak may have been the answer. ... full review
So-So, by Manisha Lakhe, Now Running.com : ...Yes, the Pakistani spy keeps saying, 'Kanda' for 'onion' which is a Marathi word used in Bombay and Maharashtra instead of the Hindi word, 'Pyaaz' which is used in Rajasthan where the story is set. This really jars the senses. The last forty five minutes are truly exciting and push the right patriotic buttons. The film falls in the could have been great category.... full review
Thumbs down, by Subhash K Jha, Bolly Spice : ...It all seems highly improbable and manipulated. By all means, honour the country with flag-waving films. But at least make sure that the film doesn’t prove unworthy of its nationalistic aspirations. ... full review
Thumbs down, by Shubhra Gupta, indian express : ...You will get the money shot of Abraham and co walking in slo-mo to swelling background music, enveloped in a comic book feel. You will not get crucial nuance and detail, essential requirements for a film to be to taken seriously. ... full review
Thumbs down, by UDITA JHUNJHUNWALA, Live Mint : ...Abraham goes all-out in portraying the sincerity and blinkered nationalism of Raina, but the character feels two-dimensional and flat. As Raina’s astrophysicist wife, Sushma, Anuja Sathe adds some wholesomeness. The actors forming Raina’s core team range from competent to comical. ... full review
Thumbs down, by Jaidev Hemmady, Movie Talkies : ...Though the team is rushing against a deadline, the sense of urgency doesn’t translate on the screen (the plot won’t make you bite your fingernails and pray for the good guys to win, if you know what I mean). Any thriller film needs great music to ramp up the tension, but ‘Parmanu’ fails in this department too, which is bound to be its undoing. If that was not all, the camera work is not slick enough, though the special effects used to show the movement of satellites and the climactic nuclear explosion, is above average. In conclusion, all said and done, ‘Parmanu’ fails on many levels and is not something that I would recommend for a weekend watch.... full review
Thumbs down, by Saibal Chatterjee, NDTV : ...Parmanu - The Story of Pokhran is as a flat as a pancake, a hopelessly limp exercise with creaky nucleus that is buried under a mound of forced tropes before it can get going. ... full review
Thumbs down, by Shrishti Nagi, News18.com : ...The good part about the movie is that just like the recently released Raazi, Parmanu too doesn’t fall into the usual trappings of bashing Pakistan on screen just to make a few extra bucks at the box office. ... full review
Thumbs down, by Sukanya Verma, Rediff : ...Laziness shrouds every aspect of this dull drama. Parmanu throws in a bulky cell phone and floppy disc to suggest its 1998, but bungles up the most obvious details. ... full review
Thumbs down, by Nandini Ramnath, Scroll.in : ...It is likely that Parmanu will be decorated with tax-free status and national film awards, and we imagine that it will be made mandatory viewing in schools across the country. The tests are two decades old, but Parmanu’s chest-thumping ardour and propaganda-level treatment are firmly of the moment. ... full review
Thumbs down, by Kennith Rosario, The Hindu : ...It makes one wonder if it is more than a coincidence that a jingoistic film like Parmanu which hails the achievement of the Atal Bihari Vajpayee government finds its footing in the current reign of the BJP. I... full review
Yash_Bhalawala: Review of Parmanu : Every heartbit dedicates to the Nation Abhishek Sharma great movie
Vivekkhiladi1: Jis jis ne parmanu movie nahi dekhi vo dekh ke aaye jabardast, awesome superb movie
vishwadeepakpa2: I saw the movie #Parmanu which really suspensive moive . Good job done by each and every character in this flim ..I enjoyed this flim
vishalpatel321: #Congratulations John bro #your new movie of #PARMANU #plz guys watch it in cinemas
vinayaksonwale: Parmanu.. Fabulous movie.. I ever seen.. Just watched with my brother @SonwaleSuresh #ParmanuPrideOfIndia #Parmanu
Vikrant71482064: Chumma duga mai apko for #ParmanuTheStoryOfPokhran @TheJohnAbraham @DianaPenty love every second in the movie parmanu
vikramabhishek: Parmanu is a great film. Well done @TheJohnAbraham
vikas2783: #Parmanu awesome movie. Must watch. It also gives a message the kind of work like Nuclear blast can be acheived by stable goverment.
Vedprak78011417: Just watched PARMANU amazing movie, should be nominated for OSCAR this year .you acted suberbly,now I am big fan of yours. @DianaPenty
tuliadhikari: Another nice and must watch movie #Pokhran ; true story and tells about the true courage of those heros we know not much about ..
trivedi_jaimin: #Parmanu awesome movie.. some of the real footages of #atalbiharivajpayee made it more special.. #ParmanuPrideOfIndia #pokhran
TheSaravagi: What an ultimate movie #Parmanu Must watch it.
thecuriouself: #Parmanu simply amazing! I absolutely loved it!! By far one of the best yet this year. Take a bow #JohnAbraham @DianaPenty
theameydave: Only one word for #Parmanu OUTSTANDING!
TechieGuy_12: To hell with critics, #Parmanu is an awesome movie and a must watch. Kudos to @TheJohnAbraham for making such a nice film.
Suryagkp94: One of the best movie in Bollywood #Parmanu @TheJohnAbraham
Shut_NoShut: So #Parmanu is a very good movie. Ab samaj me aya librandus ki itnu kyu jali hai.
shagun11: #Parmanu big thumbs up, good watch
SANJIV_13: Enjoyed the movie PARMANU. Great work by entire star cast @bomanirani @TheJohnAbraham
SanjeevJhamb: Pramanoo-The story of Pokhran A must watch movie.
sanikpalrecha: #Parmanu Best ever film
SamantaSurojit: John Abraham produces another great movie #parmanu
SachinkingGupta: Fantastic movie parmanu
Rohitpareek23: Parmanu A must watch .... John abrham Best performance
RohitGole2: #Parmanu it’s really outstanding movie @TheJohnAbraham you done great job @bomanirani also nice work @ParmanuTheMovie
RichhariyaT: Pls must watch movie parmanu
ravirajdubey: #Parmanu Amazing movie.... Just go and watch the Movie guyss... Make yourself proud.
ranjitpatil1239: watched #Parmanu outstanding movie ever made on indian history @TheJohnAbraham
rahul41210067: Just watched PARMANU....I felt like Pokhran was tested today @TheJohnAbraham
Queen36744496: #parmanu Awesome
PuneetK04754642: Parmanu movie is good ...I love it...I I'll watch again when I have time
Peeyush75943347: #PARMANU.. Kudos 2 Director 4 Making ppl aware of Hardship n Efforts faced by Army , Scientists n Engrs Beautiful Movie...Nostlagic
pankajdevshali: watched #ParmanuThePokhranStory .. Such a masterpiece.... Salute to @TheJohnAbraham sir you feel us proud.... Thanks ... #Parmanu
PAarmish: #Parmanu Parmanu must watch movie as a "INDIAN"....Great work by @TheJohnAbraham & team
official_rjr: #Parmanu is john Abraham's best movie I have ever seen.
NAYAN214: Bahot dino baat desh pe garv ho aesi picture aayi hai #Parmanu
naveena61077560: A movie which makes u proud go nd see you will never disappoint #Parmanu
mrana1123: Watched #Parmanu today feeling so proudfull aisa @deshhaimera
milisilichilli: #Parmanu #ParmanuPrideOfIndia is a must watch movie.....
Megafanist: What a beautiful film #Parmanu
MaheshKumarMK18: #Parmanu Awesome movie great team work ..and a solid comeback @TheJohnAbraham and @DianaPenty u were awesome all the very best luck
lathsiddharth: #Parmanu is pretty good movie. Good job @TheJohnAbraham You always make movies on interesting subjects.
kushvyas: #Parmanu Loved the Movie ! Thank you for this
krishnaaquatech: Yesterday watched #Parmanu movie. Simply superb movie.
Koushik40221851: #Parmanu is a best movie in @TheJohnAbraham career.when I has watched, I am speechless.
komalsihani147k: #Parmanu: WHAT A FILM! Still feeling the goosebumps. A MUST WATCH FOR EVERYONE!
KING_NV: Just watched #Parmanu what a movie.. Best @TheJohnAbraham movie ever..
KavishShrimali: Watched #Parmanu O*U*T*S*T*A*N*D*I*N*G
KamalVDhar: #JohnAbraham #Parmanu #Buddhasmiledagain... well done John
k_g_achari: Watched #Parmanu yesterday. Must watch for every Indian. Great work by @TheJohnAbraham . @bomanirani you steal the show..
imaarushak: I want #parmanu to be a super hit .
hirendhruv44: In London and just watched #Parmanu in Full house ...Speechless.. What a Movie..Bravo @TheJohnAbraham @DianaPenty #ParmanuPrideOfIndia
harshlysaid: Amazing work @TheJohnAbraham . Thank you for telling us the proud story of Pokhran. #Parmanu #Proud #JaiHind
haridas24887: Undoubtedly best movie #Pokhran. What a performance by @bomanirani must watch to see what had happened.
Gyanban: Parmanu : a good movie
GoyalJaswant2: #Parmanu देश भक्ति मूवी हैं और बहुत ही सुंदर है
GEETROCKKER: #Parmanu Mast Movie...
DograBinny: Must watch parmanu ❤ #ParmanuTheStoryOfPokhran
DocSharvil: #Parmanu Must watch Movie..!! Superb Role played by @TheJohnAbraham & @DianaPenty
DilseSpeak: Parmanu whatta movie . Outstanding, fabulous. रोंगटे खड़े कर दीये लास्ट सीन में। भारत माता की जय। जय हिंद।
Dhirajknights: Love the movie #parmanu..Best screenplay.. Good job #JohnAbraham ... salute #India #IndianArmy
DeepakM28772896: Everyone should must watch the Movie Parmanu Just go and make yourself proud
Chetan26641560: Parmanu movies best
ChavanRamS: T 1839 - #parmanu JUST OUTSTANDING !!!!!
chankalra: #Parmanu @TheJohnAbraham what a movie! Its BORDER of todays times. Fantastic
Chandra68567268: #Parmanu #Jayhind I Love #India
bunty_kamlesh: I am feeling proud after watch Parmanu movie.
Bikuengr: #Parmanu is a MUST MUST WATCH movie!
ArvindMahto26: #Parmanu Loved it, must watch movie
arunrajarao: #Parmanu nice movie Dumb @CIA Rofl
ApteVLA: #Parmanu Fantastic movie , must watch by every Indian. @vinitgoenka . John Abraham makes a great comeback to Bollywood.
anurag_duggal: #pokhran must watch for every INDIAN.. Thank you #johnabraham #bharatmatakijai #deshbhakti
AmitKum18000945: #Parmanu is awesome movie don't miss
ambuj_ak: watched #Parmanu it's just awesome... And @TheJohnAbraham thank you for choosing such patriotic movies.
ambeshpm: hey just watch out the #parmanu#filmmustwatch
akshipatel: You did such a great job in #Parmanu @TheJohnAbraham Best wishes for it. Feeling #ProudToBeIndian
Akshay_Brigade: #Parmanu One Of The Best Movie Of The Year Best Movie And Performance Of John Abraham ♡ Must Watch Flick
akhileshrathi1: #Parmanu Review :⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
AjeetPanigrahi: So proud that #pokhran was made into a movie. It's superb. Loved everything about it. Go watch. @johnabrahament
Ajaygohil19: Watched #pokhran great job Ashwat raina #JohnAbraham Today, you make us feeling proude for that unforgettable victory....
adiagarwal8: Hats off to entire team of #parmanu @TheJohnAbraham #ParmanuWinningHearts
a_blah_nari_: A well told reality of pokhran-II, parmanu is something you really should watch! @TheJohnAbraham @bomanirani @DianaPenty kudos great work❤
007DONFAN: Parmanu is a good film.
sandeepmoonka: #Parmanu good subject, mediocre execution! Movie lacks the seriousness of the subject it is dealing with
This page has additional observations, other than the ones noted in the main review.