no gossip, no scandals

movie reviews ...and more

02 Jul 09

Review - The Namesake: Beautifully simple and simply beautiful

Quick Review

This is story-telling at its best. Especially considering there was nothing very unique or great about the story itself. I was mesmerized by Tabu’s acting. Simple day-to-day dialogues and none, if not necessary added to the elegance of the movie.

In general, I like movies which have a strong compelling story. Once in a while though, comes along a movie like ‘The Namesake’ where the direction, screenplay and most importantly - the acting make you forget that the story is ‘nothing spectacular’. And this is despite the fact that it is relatively slow paced.

The story is no doubt a truthful and authentic narration of the average NRI family who moved abroad in the 70s - from the locations and sets to the accents and reactions of various characters. Especially, how Tabu and Irrfan lose the heavy Bangla accent gradually as the years go by. This could also mean that people who haven’t lived outside India for an extended period of time might not identify with the characters. They will enjoy the narrative nevertheless.

While the characters of Ashima (Tabu) and Ashoke (Irrfan Khan) are sketched out in quite some detail and are played out beautifully, some parts of Gogol’s (Kal Penn) character seemed superficial, especially his love life. By any standards, this is a Tabu movie all the way. The lady gracefully ages from a daughter to a wife to a mother. It is amazing how with just one movement of her eye, you know exactly what her character is feeling.

However, since it is a movie that tries to be as close to reality as possible, it is the missing nuances that bothered me a couple of times during the two hours. I must admit that I haven’t read the book, and this could be one of those things that didn’t find their way into the movie.

High on emotions and jerking tears along the way, this one is worth a watch just for the performances. The beauty lies in the depth of the relationships touched upon. This is one of those rare occasions where how the story is told consumes the audience rather than the story itself.

Update: Corrected spelling mistake - 'Ashim' replaced by 'Ashima'. Thanks Ashima (Comment #1 on notepad).

- meetu, a part of the audience

Detailed Ratings:

  • Direction:
  • Story:
  • Lead Actors:
  • Character Artists:
  • Dialogues:
  • Screenplay:
  • Music Director:
  • Lyrics:

The Namesake - Cast and Crew

Comments(7)

Anonymous:

I am glad that you liked it. Being a first generation immigrant in the U.S. (daughter of Meerut-born and raised parents), I really related to it. It took me a two hour drive to Chicago to see it. But it was a movie that made me call my mother right away and tell her I loved her.

posted 2 years, 11 months ago

meetu:

Am glad you did that anonymous. I identified a lot with Tabu's character.

Thanks for stopping by.

posted 2 years, 11 months ago

vikrant:

I JUST WANT TO SAY TABU WAS FAANNTAASSSTTIICCC ACTRESS SUCH A HARTH TOUSHING FILM OH MY GOD! I WOULD LIKE THANKS TO MRS.MEERA JEE, TABU , IRFAN, AND ALL CAST OF THIS FILM THESE ALLR ROCK EVERYBUDY HAVET TO WATCH IT AND REALIZE THAT WHAT IS THE MEANING OF { HEART MAILTING AND EMOTIONS } SO WHAT RU READING PEPOLE PLZ GO____________

posted 2 years, 9 months ago

Jayanta Ghosh:

I do not agree with the reviewer about the rating of the story. I and many of us coming from similar background, who immigrated to this country in the early seventies, feel that the story is an imposing drama, masterfully written in minutest details of an immigrant family struggling to cope with an alien surrounding and alien culture. We can identify ourselves with every stage of the drama and wonder how the author, though belonging to second generation of immigrants, could potray in vivid detail the life and traditions of the culture they belonged. The story also should get a rating of 4.5.

posted 2 years, 8 months ago

meetu:

Thanks for your input, Jayanta. Well, I thought Gogol's character was not fully fleshed out, especially considering that he was one of the most important character in the story. Have no complaints about how Ashima and Ashoke's characters were handled, though.

posted 2 years, 8 months ago

Meetu:

Hi Meetu,

I am your namesake it seems ;o)

Well I too have something to say about the movie...

http://mee-raj.blogspot.com/2007_07_01_archive.html

Meetu

posted 2 years, 8 months ago

meetu:

Hey namesake! Cool write-up you have there. I like the brevity of your reviews. Thanks for stopping by.


posted 2 years, 8 months ago

Leave a new comment

Ads
Recent Comments
zometa online on 'Waqt'
nHCB3g How are you? and generic keflex online and http://generic-keflex-fda.viviti.com generic keflex online and wgvv ... ...more
cheap azulfidine on 'Love Sex Aur Dhoka'
YHUdna Aloha! and lioresal and http://lioresal-fda.viviti.com lioresal and 238757 and nirdosh and http://nirdosh-fda.viviti.com nirdosh and ... ...more
zetia on 'Rock On'
OUvyUR Hello! and keftab and http://keftab-fda.viviti.com keftab and 713 and ...more
generic fatblast extreme on 'Paa'
tmSK2g Aloha! and differin and http://differin-fda.viviti.com differin and :-[[ and ...more