The poster says it loud and clear, Rani Mukherjee is going to dress as a man to play cricket. 
Cricket is after all a gentleman's game. Watching this film made me think a lot about the phrase "had its heart in the right place." And then I wonder if crores of Rupees and the writing muscle that Yash Raj is capable of mustering cannot have the art in the right place, what good is the heart doing? And by the way, such hypocricy! Rani Mukherjee definitely has a bigger role than Shahid Kapoor, but Shahid gets first billing.
The audience has outgrown Punjab, its lush green, mustard fields, the "chak de phatte"s, and the "Ik Omkar"s. It's sad that the maker's heart is still trying to juice the last drop out of them. Don't they want a change of scenery? It's been what? At least over 10 years already. Oh, and if that weren't enough, there's a bhangra beat in the background music - CONSTANTLY! Except in the songs, where it doesn't stay in the background.
Oh, and don't even get me started on the jingoistic flavor added to most characters - who are half-dimensional in the first place. "England" - bad, "Indian" - super good. No texture, no flavor to that line of thought at all.
Actually, you can't blame them for not experimenting though. It takes a fair amount of creativity to conjure a couple with Shahid Kapoor and Rani Mukerjee in it. While there was dismay guided towards this aspect of the film in dining room conversations, I was very curious to see how it worked out. And the verdict here is Shahid Kapoor looks awesome, has a cakewalk of a role for himself here where he has to alternate between romance and serious, almost play Shah Rukh of Chak De! India. Rani Mukherjee looks good too with that brilliant smile of hers, does well with her role without shrieking too much considering she's a Punjaban and all that. Oh and for those of you who were disgusted with the thought of her in a bikini, worry not, there isn't much to that negative-marketing gimmick. Together - they create zilch. You don't feel for them as a couple, you don't care if they are going to get together or not.
A huge portion of the lack of "chemistry" is of course, the story and screenplays fault. There's no flow, no scenes with impact, no nothing. It like, "a woman who aspires to be on the Indian cricket team. Hmmm…nice interesting. Let's make it into a film." How she gets there is of no consequence. You need comedy, you need romance like you need salt and pepper. Add, mix and have the audience eat it. No matter if they are gag on it.
This one from the house of Yash Raj Fairy Tales is just unacceptable. In the name of women empowerment, women are still mere props. Sure, having Rakhi Sawant and Sherlyn Chopra in the script as objects of lust, might've been a comment on the irony of women's status in Indian society, but it's in bad taste. And thus the film is not better than others which use the same premise. Oh boys, no need to rush to the theaters for this display of skin, the amount of cry-shy and drama-shama, I can guarantee won't be worth it.
- meetu, a part of the audience
Comments (11)
Absolutely Very Good Review by... Meetu....Very week story point..very week comedy...and Rani is not good to see in that Punjabi man getup...
Thank god... I almost saw this film on this Thursday. And last minute decided to go in for Unnai Pol Oruvan (Tamil remake of Wednesday)...
Now I can see that it was a very good decision....
@nareshallu thank you!
@Anoop glad to be of help!
I was quite put off with the fact that a movie that pretends to be about equal opportunities for men and women, has such strong gender bias. In the climax, Rani is completely at Shahid's mercy to play or sit. Even though she takes the team to victory, she does not even win Man of the Match - that goes to the hero. It is he who decides when it's time for her to reveal her identity, not she. So much for women's empowerment.
@Shuchi extremely annoying...yes!
"actually it yells, get outta here!" lol very true, If only I had followed your review I wouldn't have been mentally harassed in the theater !
@shardul That's what you get for not listening to your elders! Ha!!
your movie review is awesome.I m agree from u that this is a movie for women's empowerment,but still something is totally missing from movie,may be it is from wrong marketing or lack of chemistry
Actually the runs hit by indian team are unacceptable,specially from rani.Overall movie is only timepass.
I think Dil bole Hadippa was a film was amazing, The dances, musics, the places was colorfull and it were nice. The chemistry between Rani an Shahid was good too :D
Even i think dil bole hadippa was an amazing film
well everyone has different opinions
I was originally going to say "Aw, but I liked this movie, meetu!" - but then I read your review...and everything you said was Spot-On! The best part of the movie by a long shot was Rani Muhkerjee as a crack female cricketeer who disguises herself as a male Sikh to play on the Indian Cricket Team (and some day, I'll remember to put the "h" before "k" when singing her praises on an Indian Film Review site). It's also fun seeing Anupam Kher again.
As for the rest...? Yeah, it was pretty dire, between the rhapsodic talk and singing about the pure honest magical glories of the Punjab like some American Far Right propaganda film (we saw this right about the time we also saw NAMASTEY LONDON and DILWALE DULHANIA LE JAYENGE), and how the screenplay tried to have its sexist cake and eat it too as an feminist empowerment saga. I think Shahid Kapoor was appropriately cast as an arrogant British cricketeer - which may be part of the problem, since he never really unbent all that much even when he was supposed to.
Still, Ms. Muhkerjee's performance says all the screenplay elides or outright denies - and single-handedly almost saves this movie.
Leave a new comment