movie reviews ... and more
Review - Tare Zameen Par: A lesson for parents & teachers
Tare Zameen Par
![[Poster for Tare Zameen Par]](http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2763/4116452397_0e4af05a8c_m.jpg)
How can one not love a movie about children crafted with utmost compassion - children with special needs at that? But, is that the only reason I liked Tare Zameen Par? Maybe - maybe not. What I know for sure is that a strong one-line story is narrated extremely charmingly. It is truly uplifting when spirit wins and yet, it is not all about the spirit of winning.
Tare Zameer Par is about a child who suffers because no one around him recognizes that he is a slow learner. The beauty of the narration is that the message applies to all children - learning disability or not. How can creativity not deserve a place in academics? It also points a very subtle finger at how we build conformation in our system right at the roots.
The pace of the first half gives you time to think of normal children who are just not academically inclined. The resolution in the second half, however, comes by too quickly compared to the trauma shown earlier. But, I guess, if the point is to show that difficulties can be overcome, you don't necessarily want to show how difficult it is to overcome them.
About 45 minutes post-interval, Darsheel Safary (Ishaan) said a line which made me realize that he hadn't said a line in the last hour or so. There I was feeling sorry for Ishaan, feeling like yelling at someone to give him a big hug while I fought this lump in my throat that had been there for the longest time. All this based solely on Darsheel's expressions and body language!
Kudos to the director for taking this decision and many such with brilliant confidence. And, finally we have a dialogue writer who knows when not to give the actors a helping hand. There are a couple of verbose, preachy scenes. But, they made the point because they were well written.
Aamir Khan's entry into the movie seemed over-the-top and forced, mainly because it was in absolute contrast with the tone of the movie thus far. But after a little while you realize that you can't distinguish between the actor/director Aamir Khan and his character Nikhumb. They are both fighting the same cause. Passionately. The other characters serve their purpose as caricatures - stereotypical father, loving mother, understanding sibling, ruthless teacher, and jeering peers.
No matter who or what the focus of the camera is, the love it feels towards its subjects shows in each frame. And, in turn, you fall in love with what you see on screen. Compositions, lighting, angles, colors all work successfully together to engross you and very often to enchant you. The lingering camera might have added a good 10-15 minutes to the run-time. But you will be hard-pressed to point out exact scenes which the movie could have done without. Everything is building character or atmosphere or both.
The songs too contribute to the narrative. The lyrics are sheer poetry. I know-I know, that's what they are supposed to be, but can't remember the last time lyrics brought me to tears. "mein kabhi batlaata nahi" kept me speechless (and we all know how difficult that is!). And rock-style guitar strumming to a kids' song - that's what I call creative.
Yes, that dash of seemingly inevitable melodrama exists. The side-characters transform for no apparent reason. The climax is exaggerated and is as unrealistic as it could get. However, the aim is to show not reality of life but reality of the condition that this child suffers from. Once you get that, you pardon the make-up a mother is wearing at 6 AM while doing her chores. And anyway, most of this is towards the end, by which time you are willing to forgive. Because, above all else, it makes you think.
When did we grow up? When along the way did we forget what it felt like to be yelled at, to be put down, to be ridiculed? And why did we choose the next generation for revenge? Will we recognize the child in us that is struggling to get out? Will the sensation that the lump in the throat created, stay after the credits roll?
- meetu, a part of the audience
Tare Zameen Par - Movie Details
- Official Sites: Website
- Producer: Aamir Khan
![[Has twitter account]](/site_media/images/icons/twitter_small.png)
- Director: Aamir Khan
- Lead Cast: Aamir Khan, Darsheel Safary
- Supporting Cast: Tanay Cheda, Sachet Engineer, Tisca Chopra, Vipin Sharma
- Story: Amole Gupte
- Cinematography: Setu
- Editor: Deepa Bhatia
- Music Director: Shankar Mahadevan, Ehsaan Noorani, Loy Mendonca
- Lyrics: Prasoon Joshi
- Running time: 160 minutes
- Reviewer: meetu
- Categories: Hindi Movies
- Genres: Family, Kids, Social
Tare Zameen Par - Trailer
Tare Zameen Par - All reviews summary
External Reviews
39 reviewers have given Tare Zameen Par an average rating of 4.6/5.0. 34 yays, 2 nays, 3 so-so. See all external reviews »
Comments (79)
hey meetu .. u can uplaod this review too.. not tht i agree with it, but it is quite different from the majority of taare reviews.
http://movies.indiatimes.com/moviereview/2638576.cms
I agree with almost everything you've written in the review, except that I did not feel it was lesson for parents and teachers only. It's a BIG lesson to everyone; just accept each other for who and what they are...I am good, so are you!
I am all praises for Aamir Khan. Oh! and Darsheel Safary too, but I guess it takes a good director to create good actor out of a kid, so, the credit goes to Aamir again.
This was one movie that made me cry, like *really* feel and cry. And I mean it in the best sense (I was happy watching the film). The emotions were portrayed SO well!
Hey Meetu... that was real quick... Generally we have wait for several days to see ur review but this time u made it on the first day!! Anyway i am looking forward to see this movie on Big screen!! Bas Tickets nahi mil rahe.. :(
Great start from the director in Aamir. Simply lovely!!
Naina, done! Thanks for the link.
Pooja, I know exactly what you mean!
TinuAnand, I in variably have at least one review out on Friday evening. The only Friday I have missed as far as I can remember is November 9th because it was Diwali. So, do check every Friday! Do not miss this one in the theaters and do come back and let us know what you thought!
Biswa, absolutely!!
Can't we give 6/5 to director and lyricist ? They deserve it.
hi
i think the movie is fantastick......... it makes the audience to think out of the conventional box at least in the matter of children ........ the children those who are weak in the conventional studies....... it is also an well directed by the debutant Amir Khan as director...... as a actor he is my hero........... it will be sad if move will not be hit ......... but it is imperative that movie will not be as hit the other bollywodd movies are .......... reat is well made movie............
hi..
i still not see this movie but i am waiting for it from a long time...
and i hope it will be very good.....
The movie is simply outstanding. Music is just appropriate. For all of those who are trying to critically judge the movie and are trying not to over-rate the movie, should just chill out for sometime and keep their comments for the “other commercial cinema”. This moive is simply outstanding and deserves a huge applause, plain and simple. Aamir Khan has made the Indian cinema proud.
Taare Zameen par was a heart touching movie. It is brillantly directed and the movie is as perfect as Aamir Khan. He has always been a powerful force in making his movies a complete finished product and now we see his total dedication in bringing out one of the best movies Bollywood or rather the world has ever seen. This is Oscar material.
check my blog: http://bollywoodtrends.blogspot.com for moview review on Taare zameen par
[...] Meeta Kabra [Without giving the movie away] [...]
movie is simple but verymuch impresive ,everyone should should see it atleast once
one of the best work ive seen in bollywood since rang de basanti....probably one of the best films of all time...
I m speechless, the way the Aamir has directed and acted in the film. It is simply awesome and heads up to him.
lovely.the way a child behaves is shown with the utmost care hats off aamir wonderful music by the team the song meri maa is very brillianttttttttttttttt.i have 2 sons n i never thot that they think this way.its an eye opener.very close to every parents heart .aamir thanx for saving our children from anytraumaaa.awesome awesomeawesome a standing ovasion 2 u sweetheart
hats off
i hope the moviev will be outstanding ..i have not seen yet .i m really curious about this movie. i love Amir
[...] also had lumps in her throat at Darsheel’s portrayal of Ishaan. There I was feeling sorry for Ishaan, feeling like yelling at someone to give him a big hug while [...]
The work done by Amir is very fantastic , while watching movie u wil never feel boaring thaks to Amir for that very well done Amir
BEAUTIFUL MOVIE
Aamir Khan is AMAZING!!! it is like he is not even acting, so real.
Aamir Khan .......is just Aamir Khan. Unique.
helllo meetu u wrote appropriate and very helpful review, its a worthy watch ........ hats off to aamir, superb action from boy(ishaan) this credit goes to director. aamir is going to break many records, best picture i ever seen and best picture in 2007, i broken into tears many times, heart touching movie, excellent farewell to 2007. Eye opener to parents and teachers.....
every one should watch this movie..
taare zameen par is a very heart touching movie. its very emotional and u can feel wat the boy feels in the movie.
the direction has been done in a fantastic manner. it all goes to Aamir khan.
the movie has widen'd the thoughts of every parent and every human being.
it's said true;
"EVERY CHILD IS SPECIAL"
[...] gift as it receives rave reviews in its first week. Meetu (without giving the movie away) gives it a Must-See rating. How can one not love a movie about children crafted with utmost compassion - children with special [...]
Hi all,
TZP Really touched my heart,
The day next i saw the film the child mischif and the sarrow used pass my mind every now and then,
This story is a kind of similar to my life,
I belong to a middle class family from …
Because i too had school fobia in my child hood,
Yes i was a really bad at reading and playing games like other kids,
I belong to a middle class family,
I used to hate school and i left home for 8 months i travelled all of india with out money,
Luckely i came back to home and
my old school throwed me out then i got in to new governament school where i felt i am better than most of childrens,
I saw my school mates who are worste than me and teachers did not had much issuee with me,
Just like the kid i was suffering ,
But here no amir kan in my life ,
I felt i am good as the governament school,
Thanks that i found my luck and i was thrown out of english school,
They used to beat like dogs and cats,
Its a very big story,
Every teacher should know that children are not slaves,
And parents should understand childs difficulty insted of beating them like dogs,I know every teacher cant affort time for every body but a little change in all teacher can bring up the kids,
I found my way,
Yep i passed SSLC which no one would have ever thought off who knew me,
Now i am 26,
And working as a software engineer in a MNC,
Today i solved a bug so i have free time to write on this blog,
But there are 1000 like me,
I may not visit this blog again in my lifetime,
But my message to all viewers of this blog,
Please if u ever get a chance to be a part of teacher or in feture ur kid might have a poor learning skill like that child ishan,
please understand them and try to give them love and never break the confidence in such a way bring them.
Thank your for reading,
And Special thanks to amir for his time and effort to bring a good story,
TC
Bye
Love you all,
Wow... Just wow....
i like this movie like anything i still cry as i rember song of maa ,, this movie dosent come out of my mind brlliant amir for such movie
its amazing movie a lesson 4 all parents n teacher supurb work hats of 2 aamir khan he is smply gr8 though i m shahrukh khans big big fan but but now i olve amir too
the movie touch my soul
Liked the review except the subtitle "A lesson for parents & teachers".
Though nothing wrong about the way it was done but the complete 9 x 3 = 3 was actually a rip off from calvin n hobbes sunday strip.
But overall the movie was just EXCELLENT.
The direction was flawless. You can't point out a single instance when there was any mistake in screenplay,dialogues or in the expression of even any out-of-focus performer.
good movie for every one, must watch, much better than to qualify for the Oscar,
I myself is a Physical therapist and has treated Physically n mentally challenged kids.
Its great to find someone made an effort bring the cruel truth in public.
The larger answere to these kids queries lies in having more and more people getting aware and get involved in upgrading these kids.
The movie was undoubtly the masterpiece and need more and more of movies on such topics.
A great movie and an equally good review :-)
I must say Meetu this is your finest review (according to me). You actually penned down everyone's feeling :-).
> “mein kabhi batlaata nahi” kept me speechless
Same here. I too can't remember the last time when the lyrics made me cry. Each and every sentence of all the songs is so appropriate it actually justified the use of Songs in Bollywood Movies ;)
Just there is this feeling of incompleteness. Everyone is praising Darsheel, Aamir, Prasoon... but people are not talking much about Amole. That mysterious controversy between him and AK is also cause of my sympathy for him. In spite of being AK's great fan I feel very sorry for Amole. And I hope this great guy will be able to direct his next film :-)
Regards,
- Ashish K.
I congratulate the Amir Khan and his team from the botom of my heart for making such an excellent movie "Taare Zamin Par". I found that, Amir Khan is not only an actor/director, but also a philosopher. This movie, itself is a lesson for parents and teachers that teaches, How to deal with children?
Thanks universelingal!
Thanks Thejesh, it would be great feedback to know why.
Puneet - i think, copying or "getting inspired" is okay if it is done well.
Thanks a ton, Ashish K!
Renuka(critic of timesgroup) must take rest, have a good sleep ..feel fresh and then watch the movie. Write a review only if you understand what you are talking about! In the whole movie you felt that the director is only trying to create awareness about "Dyslexia"? How poor imagination of a Movie Critic!! Haven't you seen your childhood in the movie, haven't you realized that how mechanical the modern parents are, haven't you realized that loss of emotion of a small child after getting detached from his parents in a forceful manner? Renuka, you need a brake, I am sorry to write that you have a learning deficiency too and that is due to lack of emotions… look back at your childhood you'll find out the cause of the damage. Good Luck!
Debashish Chowdhury, Kuwait
To be honest, I have almost never written a review for a move! But this make me go out take the effort to write one, It is THE best movie I have seen. I am a part-time social worker, so this movie touches me more! I used to write b as d, and vice versa. In the character of the father, I see my own father. Believe me it causes more pain than one can ever imagine!
If someone has not seen this movie, I would personally recommend them to see the movie. I have saving this movie for ever in my heart. I hope this movie gets nominated for Oscars, it truly deserves it by all means! Previous movies by Aamir Khan do not compare one bit to this! Truly this is THE best movie I have seen, I cannot repeat it again! I really hope all of the world does not miss it. It has one of the most strongest messages that I have seen in Indian movies.
I see myself in this movie! I think that teachers in India should pay more attention to their students at an early age and show them a way instead of put pressure on them and push them to a corner in the rat-race of life! It is a pity that I had to go through that I hope this movie convinces that both parents and teachers and more so the society pays attention to small children to avoid such mishaps! I does cause a large impact to a child and his future.
Hats of Aamir for this classic, You reminded Mahboob Khan, Guru Dutt, Bimol Roy, Satyajeet Ray, HK Mukherjee & Many more. We Salute you for your great contribution to Indian Cinema. The Best movie about Kids I have seen after Mani Rathnams ANJALI.
Above All SHAME TO OTHER KHANS (Three Big S-S-S)in Bollywood.
"3 Tickets?Taare Zameen par," I asked at the Advance Booking counter.A
guy next to me said,"Arre Welcome ka show hai naa??".His friend looked
at the poster and predicted,"Mast timepass rahegi!".Hmmm..I
thought..Should I also take Welcome?Who wants to get bored for 3 hrs
anyway?By the time I could decide,the counterwalla had the tickets
ready for me.Disappointedly I paid and said to myself,"Chal na.Iske
baad Welcome dekh lenge".
The introduction started with jumbling letters and a colourful
animation. Then I saw water.And a face. Face with a focused
look..innocently sticking his tongue out in concentration.His aim?
Kidnap fishes from the gutter.
I think I had moist eyes.Was I seeing the 8-yr old...ME? For the next
2.5 hrs I had frequent chocking lumps in my throat with an inability to
breathe properly. Sounds like torture. But Felt like magic.. :)
I think by this time we all know what the movie is all about.And also
its flaws-thanks to some _____(don't know what) out there in the world
who don't have enough capacity to enjoy anything fully.
I am writing this column only for those who pointed out flaws in the
movie.I have a question for you guys.
How many movies have you so
critically-intellectually-arrogantly-insensitively analysed? Or should
I ask,"How many movies have you even analysed?".This movie has got even
the non-writers writing for it,discussing the
angles,quality,direction,scene details and what not.Can you think why?
I didn't find any interesting blog discussing about the technical details
of OSO,Welcome,Partner etc etc..What is making us discuss so much about
TZP guys??
Its the impact that the movie made on you.The tears which were rolling
down your eyes..the helpless expressions of Ishaan which forced you to
introspect..and probably the overly critical nature of his father and
teachers..which you want to defend.
TZP is above any criticism or any cynic who knows the price of
everything and the value of nothing(thank you Nikumbh Sir). You guys
criticized the movie for being slow,Amir crying too much,having seen
some empty beds,oversized clothes,unnecessary songs...How come you TZP-critiques forgot
to criticize Ishaan's father? How come you guys forgot to criticize the
way his art teacher punished him?How come you guys forgot to criticize
the sports teacher for fairing pathetically at the painting
competition??
Probably because these people reflect a little of you all...
Get a life friends. If you keep judging TZP,you'll have no time to love
it.
On a light note..What if I had been razor sharp to stop that
counterwaala from tearing the tickets and had instead taken the tickets
of Welcome???? Sigh...
Taare Zameen Par.
A movie which made me realise that
Sometimes in life,it is healthy to be slow and dumb.
Taare Zameen par was a heart touching movie with beautiful songs specially maa.... and tare zameen par.it makes me cry. i feel this is one of my best movie in my life.there are some moments in movie when u can not stop yourself to cry.This movie have message to parents and teachers.i was waiting this movie since a long time but i can not imagen this how beautiful this movie is.
This movie teaches a lesson to the guardian as well as teacher how to behave their child or student, behaving abnormal or very different from the behavior of common children. This movie is really great i love the role of the child by name Ishant in the movie and i admire Aamir, its director and story writter. This movie will be appreciated by every class of the society so this is its beauty.
Shail
A MOVIE TO REMEMBER
this movie is really needed for like indian country child.The teacher must see this movie and also see the parents.The movie said that every child has power and ability to do any research tipe activity.
when i was seeing the movie i felt as if my brother's childhood is being played in front of me once again (he is 15 yrs younger to me) and i wished he too had gt a teacher like RAM character played by mr amir khan may b he culd b a different person
the movie deals with a subject tht our society shuns to talk abt but is a very necessary one as many children these days r suffering from this problem
parent's and teachers both shuld take it as a challenge instead of running from it as amir khan says in the movie tht he knows the symptom but the parents need to find out wht is the cause of those symptoms
the movie went straight to my heart as i had some similar experiences while dealing with my brother
the direction is supurb
the new boy darsheel has done pure justice to his role
every thing in the movie is too good film makers shuld make more movies on this subject as they play a very imp role in the lives of common people
it's really odd or rather unbelievable to expect a film like TZP from Bollywood. in most cases these type of films never mark anything in so called box office i.e. "Khamoshi,Akele Hum Akele Thum".... but without any doubt TZP will mark the top place in minds of the people who looking for genuine stuff, welldone Aamir,,,,preicious Khan....Mahesh-Colombo
THATS A REALLY GOOD MOVIE BUT I WAS A BIT BORED AT THE END (THE PAINTING COMPETING) THAT WHERE THE MOVIE SLOWSDOWN~~~STILL I WOULDGIVE 3.5/5
[...] (old) blog post by Aamir Khan about the process they followed for recording the background score of Tare Zameen Par which I found very interesting: The work on the TZP background score is going rather well I think. [...]
Hey Good Lord....I could not still get over the heavy heart after watching the movie. Amir has shown it that it is not stardom...you need to create a niche for yourself...all that old clad that we used to talk about...Rajkapoor, Gurudutt...I guess he has a long way to go and hats of to him to create TZP.
I relate the entire sequence to me..my childhood...I never liked studies...because it was always imposed on me...I myself do not know how I got off the school and the college....but believe me..the inner strength is not made of always academics...
I have 3 children...two of them my own and one adoped....the adopted son is a carbon copy of me...he came to us as an angel when he lost both his parents and the trauma was heavy on his heart (he was only six when he lost his parents)...he is smart..he is agile but does not want to study...I relate each scene of the film with my life...We as parents often bully ourselves and when dont understand to tackle a situation, often become aggressive to cover up ourselves....
Its a while something has touched me so far...Kudos to Amir Khan productions
If I were to take up a social cause, I have decided that it would be children. Do let me know if anyone requires any kind of help for institutions or schools which I would be happy to become a member.
Cheers once again
its a grand movie
we were really enjoyed and learnt something
hi aamir u r a creator like mr. bhansali
u r too good .aap sada khush rahien aur isi tarah li outstanding movies create karte rahen
Hi Meeta Ji,
It was a week ago I watched the movie Taare Zameen Par and a week after that I thought to read some of the reviews regarding the movie.So, I just google searched for the movie review and right now I am extremely delighted to get your site full of well written reviews regarding the hindi movies.
The way you scrutinize every details of the film and the way you critically analysize every aspect of the film have most drawn my attention.
So, from now onwards I have decided to go through your movie review before watching the movie.
Hats off to your effort.
Thanks Sailesh!
its been a very good story in which it has been told about children that all are not the same every child has some weak & strong points also that everyone has different thinking & way of expressing also the parents should look forward to the child and his problems
it is a very touching movie. darsheel and amir khan did fantastic job
A must-watch movie.U'll never know that you are watching a film..Because u can never stop crying looking at that kid..
The TEAM deserves an award..
the best filim i ever have seen.i cried a lot..it really became a pain in my heart..i will be always thankful to the whole team for contributing the wonderful story.especially anmole gupta,aamir khan,deepti bhatia and my dearest darsheel safary.its my humble request toanyone for send me any details for conact them.
he is really like my sweet brother..love you darsheel...you did a goo job.
i love this movi becoz it is so good i like it and i like the role of amir khan
TZP what a wonderful cinema for children. my baby long time watch this cinema.my babies r 2.5 years oldand 5+. they like this cinema very much.
hi this movie is just mirrror of my life till now
when i saw this moivie i just rembered my childhood that passed these years me too dyslecic
wonderful movie...theres no doubt AAMIR is the best actor but he proved it again by directing such a amazing movie...keep it up,,,,hope u dont direct the same story line again....can watch it once,,,something new...
it's one of the best movie in indian cinema. amir gives great film to us.its proud of indian cinema.
I dont know hindi fluently,i saw this movie in DVD with english titles. The movie created by aamir and team is master piece of indian cinema. I am unable to come out of the feelings created by ishaan.Merem ma song is marvellous.All parents must see.
Nice movie,good story,direction and acting.
One of the glitches I felt in the movie (while watching for the third time) is
when Aamir's character asks Rajan (while waiting for the art competition to start) where Ishaan is? Rajan answers that Ishaan left
early from hostel before anyone got up. How come Rajan knew about this? We knew that he lived
in the staff quarters and not in the hostel..(it can be argued that he came to know this from another student..but
it felt like this was something that the director overlooked).
Ok, you got me. that was probably one of the greatest movie i have ever seen. TAARE ZAMEEN PAR
I watched this wonderful movie on an "Emirates flight" from Dubai to Los Angeles. One of the very best movies I have ever watched. I could not hold my tears back especially the tears of joy at the ending. Deserves all awards including the "Oscar" to encourage Hollywood and Bollywood to produce more such moveis instead of worthless "Jishum .... Jishum" craps.
D BESST MOVIE EVA!!!!!!!!!!!
NO ONE CAN LIKE DIS MOVIE AS MUCH AS I DO!!
JUST HANG YOUR SLUMDOG MILLIONAIRTE N WATCH THIS... THIS MASTERPIECE.
Aamir Khan's charm and brilliance has worked yet again.It's not just a movie,it's an advice to follow for generations to come.
this is a must watch movie.tears start rolling down when you look at that kid.
great movie!
i like Tare Zameen Par a nice flim,no words to tell about it a good story good direction .i am an fan of Aamir Khan.
this movie was in my heart and it is still there. In the modern world we have a lot of problems to accept each other for who and what they are. We need develop then skills. Because only then can we live peacefully
best movie ever. cant help but to feel attached to Ishaan. very good acting for darsheel. hhe succesfully engraved his character in our minds and heart. a must see movie for all parents, teachers and students. this is a classic. Ive seen this movie here in the philippines a few days ago and i just cant shrug off my mind the character ishaan. missed my nephew a lot who looks like ishaan
The movie was very an inspirational. Every scene tuoched and soften my heart that i cried hard enough to heaven. the connotes a hearstring and awaken the minds of the teachers who cant understand the individual dirrences. i really love the movie, is best movie i ever seen.I felt so much better after watching the movie. The movie which a child may or may not understand but one which every parent/teacher should watch to understand their child. i recommend this movie to all, spicially the teachers.
I have seen many hindi movies about the plight of children Mother India was the most powerful, this particular movie has delivered strong messages about the misfortunes and suffering of childern was again.
Aamir Khan is an actor whom I rate very highly as his ability to adapt into character and carry the strong screen prescence is unprecendented amongst the modern Indian film stars. He is definitely one of my favourites his apperance in Lagaan was top notch.
http://www.vimax-review.com/
http://www.vimax-review.com/do-vimax-pills-work
http://www.vimax-review.com/vimax-free-trial
http://www.vimax-review.com/vimax-video-testimonial
i am shoked with the type of dieses which showout in this movie.
1. Ishaan's father has been shown as a reckless and emotionless person, he himself could have changed Ishaan if he had shown love n care to him right from start. Just because he wears a Coat/Suit/Speaks english/drives car & carries laptop/ does not mean he is a professional.
2. Why should Ishaan wake up and leave the hostel @ such a dawn time, is it to enjoy nature to get a grip of what he has to make for his painting ?
3. Why does Nandu's dialogue so vague in the House scene, when he asks Ram Shankar, whether his son is not normal and retarded, when Aamir denies this, Vipin himself asks what'z the use of paintings as acc.to him it useless which means he makes up his mind that he is a retard in a indirect way.
After watching movie several times in the Native language, I could clearly make out, the subject's father (Vipin Sharma) has been portrayed as a 21st Century very demanding, impatient and cocky personality, who has no patience to listen to excuses and feels kids should study on their own, even a Single weekend getaway with his textbooks/notebooks could have made him figure out what the problem could possibly be, had he been more lenient and friendly, I am sure Ishan would have opened up with his problem of stating the LETTERS ARE DANCING. His Dad was only demanding, never gave him a chance to speak up,
Leave a new comment