no gossip, no scandals.
movie reviews ... and more
wogma tip: Don't want to read sooo much? Listen to audio reviews under the 'quick review' of the film.

Patiala House - Preview

Patiala House

wogma rating: Watch when on TV (?)
quick review: The more number of non-engineers/CAs/MBAs/doctors I meet, the more I hear, "oh I did my engineering for my parents, but this is (films/writing/dancing) where my heart lies. We have had many movies that comment on our inept system and control-freak older generation, they usually become a tad too dark. Patiala House keeps the balance towards being light. But completely messes up the good, strong start that it gives itself by going the clichéd route.
Click here to see latest tweets by this movie's official account

Akshay Kumar - My system is now trained to bring a flow of reflex actions at the mention of the name - that of a grimace, which turns into a cringe and ends in a shudder. And that's sad because we have seen glimpses of the actor in him in Aankhen and if I remember right, Khakee. I know that's too few and way too far between considering the colossal blunders that he has made since then. But the 'never say die' spirit in me still looks for those glimpses, after all I go there to watch a good film.


So after neutralizing the Akshay-Kumar effect, I set out to watch the trailer.




This one completely leaves me with mixed feelings. The themes it seems to be touching upon interest me a lot - racism; the confusion that the second generation of Indians abroad faces; the disparity in the thinking process of generations. And at the same time, I'm so worried that the fight against discrimination very quickly turns into jingoism; talk about generation gap transforms into glorifying family values beyond what they are and so on.


Fortunately there are enough decent dialogues in there, to even out this skepticism. So the fingers are crossed. Only not too tightly, because director Nikhil Advani has also given us Chandni Chowk to China and no one can be forgiven for such a thing. And this is coming from someone who enjoyed most of Salaam-e-ishq. I can only imagine how wary the people who hated that one too must be, if they care enough in the first place that is.


Oh yeah, and how can we forget Ms. Anoushka Sharma who just might tilt the balance in the film's favor.

Anyhow, the songs are a mixed bag too. The pacy ones are not too inspiring and can't imagine them motivating anyone to go to the theaters. But the softer songs are playing on a loop right now.


Music reviews:

milliblog - "gains a lot from its elegant melodies!"

music aloud - "8.25/10"

Apun Ka Choice - "3/5"

Bollyspice - "1.5/5"

Bollywood Hungama - "4/5"

HappySing - "Overall, Patiala House may not be among the best of Shankar Ehsaan Loy, but like most of their albums, the album has some freshness, and some good ol’ things."

IANS - "neither bad nor brilliant"

Rediff - "3.5/5"

Glamsham - "4/5"

Patiala House - Movie Details

Patiala House - Trailer

If you cannot see a video above, click here to see it on YouTube

Patiala House - All reviews summary

External Reviews

48 reviewers have given Patiala House an average rating of 2.3/5.0. 14 yays, 17 nays, 17 so-so. See all external reviews »

Twitter Reviews

On twitter, 181 twitterers have given Patiala House an average rating of 3.5/5.0. 117 yays, 42 nays, 22 so-so. See all tweets »

Readers' Ratings

2 readers have given Patiala House an average rating of 3/5.0. 0 yays, 0 nays, 2 so-so. See all reader reviews »

Comments (9)

ligne:

i quite like laung da lashkara..is that on the softer or faster side?

UK Desi:

I don't see how a story on racism can turn into Jingoism unless you think white racists are actually RIGHT in attacking Indians (which would lead into the Pro-White Supremacist mentality) and let's not get into institutional racism that Indians faced in the UK (and probably still do)

meetu:

@ligne laung da laskara is one of the ones i thought was ok.

@UK Desi Like Dhana dhan Goal. I don't understand how anyone is to win this fight against racism by calling British locals 'ye gore' or 'ye kaale' in a derogatory tone. The Indians living abroad that hate the locals so bad, shouldn't they come back to India? There is no racism against Indians here. Or are they then bothered by the blatant poverty, dust and all things not-so western? My point is them discriminating against us doesn't make us great or our use of derogatory language right.

NRIs giving out 'holier than thou' spiels while conveniently enjoying everything else about the country they live only sounds like misplaced patriotism - both in reality and in films

Jai:

Meetu it appears we are on the same page. Calling angrez "gorey" is definetly derogatory. Using an adjective such as gora as a noun to describe a "people" is never a nice thing. Why are these hindi films all painting the indian experience in the UK as being a surpressed oppreseed minority? i.e there was a film about a younng man unable to play for a football team because he was indian once too so he joined the ethnic exclusive indian team of southall. Indians are one the most sucesfull here. Racism exists, but not on the scale of the 70's even the 80's. do they (hindi film industry) even know of the experience of UK born desi people here? are they bothered about showing that? or they going to have indians from indian portray there idea of what they believe indian lives are like here? Whats the agenda? Once in in hindi films desi abroard were westernised namak harami types ie. roti kapda aur makaan. Now they are NRIs, poor NRIs under seige from the narrow minded "Gorey". Why Are we being told the other is against us? Who is really the narrow minded ones here?

meetu:

@Jai exactly, what i was trying to say!

corporate trophies:

I'll be quite happy if I get to see any of these movies.

guddu:

akshay from now on you'd better find an editing job for youself and may god bless you

sudhan from callezee:

quiet interesting to see and laugh.

Mansi:

the first few minutes completely set the mood.. but it drifts into the same monotonousness after a point!

And yes,
"It might not stay fresh for too long if she continues to play the same type of a role again and again, though."
have expressed the same on my blog...
http://eatpraylovemovies.blogspot.com/2011/02/patiala-house-2011.html

Leave a new comment