no gossip, no scandals.
movie reviews ... and more
wogma tip: Don't like wogma reviews? No problemo! Leave your opinion, add your rating for films and write your 100-character review in the comments section.

Aisha - Preview

Aisha

wogma rating: Watch when on TV (?) - chick-flick warning
quick review: Aisha has clueless characters breathing fresh air. Sonam Kapoor and Ira Dubey, try to carry this 'by women, for women' film, though it suffers from too plain a story. Director, Rajeshree Ojha has decent intentions but Aisha fumbles and stumbles downhill.

NOT A REVIEW - Just wondering if Abhay Deol can pull off a regular, commercial-film type role alongside Sonam Kapoor who is clearly THE protagonist Aisha

* * *

21-year old entrepreneurs - I have a few friends who meet the description - One the founder of an online life-style activism magazine and a restaurant ; another who runs a social media company. And it still makes me proud to read that the latest producer in the industry was 21 when she started working Aisha. I don't know her, nor am I 'connected to her' in the farthest meaning of the phrase. There's just something extremely healthy about kids getting hands-on experience and trying their skills out in real life.

Apparently, the entire Aisha team is very young. Director, Rajshree Ojha is not yet 30 either. You do expect many new ideas; hope for fresh take on whatever issue they pick; rejuvenation of old themes using a novel narrative style. And then the trailer leaves you with mix feelings. Granted it looks like a romantic story with a difference, yet something made me wary. Or maybe it's just the anxiety of having decent hopes set up by the promos, mercilessly crushed in these past few weeks.

Abhay Deol's presence in this trailer is extremely comforting. Even though, it's clear that the film is all about Aisha. Oh yeah, isn't that fresh? I know a lot of Aisha's character from these two minutes - certainly more than I sometimes could say about the female lead in an entire Hindi film. Which says a lot, because that means there is a lot to know about Aisha, right?

As evil as it sounds, another reassuring factor is that Rajshree struggled to find producers. Because, that means her script is trying to break the norm -

Enough of Hollywood films have been copied to make Bollywood hits. I want to take a Bollywood film and make a film in Hollywood

...

Satyajit Ray is my favourite director and one day I would like to adapt a book of his and make a film on it.

Meanwhile Aisha is based on Jane Austen 's 'Emma'. That in itself is breaking the norm, no? Giving credit and all. Given this background I'm intrigued by the Hannah Montana meets Barbie meets young socialite feel I get from the promo and marketing tactics .

I'm sure most films go through an ordeal to get the 'look' of the protagonists right. But Aisha 's marketing goes out of its way to talk about the clothes . They also emphasize wherever they can that the character is a fashion statement herself.

The effort that has gone into the clothes may remind the audiences of glamorous-looking movies like Devil Wears Prada, Priceless and Sex and the City.

There is more stuff here that makes you look forward to a happy-and-yet-good film compared to smiling-faces-in-climax-which-want-to-make-you-cry. If the word in the blog world and film magazines is right, the music has already done the good deed. Milliblog is impressed with every track in the album. Apun ka choice has a question for music director, Amit Trivedi , "Oh boy! Where were you?" Blogger, Sahil Bhalla calls it 'Genius'. The other descriptive phrases used are youthful and entertaining and
a complete package.

This article was first published at meetu's Times of India Blog.

Aisha - Movie Details

Aisha - Trailer

Aisha - All reviews summary

External Reviews

53 reviewers have given Aisha an average rating of 2.0/5.0. 9 yays, 19 nays, 25 so-so. See all external reviews »

Readers' Ratings

4 readers have given Aisha an average rating of 2/5.0. 1 yays, 2 nays, 1 so-so. See all reader reviews »

Comments (23)

joydeep:

Eagerly waiting to see the chemistry between Abhay Deol and Sonam Kapoor.

Shilpa:

Has anyone seen the movie "Clueless", starring alicia silverstone? The promos of Aisha look a lot like Clueless.

So, is it more aesthetic to say, based on a classic novel? rather then saying a remake of Clueless...

I am clueless :-))

rekha:

actually there are several versions of emma, including a movie called emma itself. The basic storyline is the same in every one of them, so I am not sure there is any reason to give clueless credit for the same..except perhaps if at all the modern adaptation?

Shilpa:

Right, let's wait and watch. But the emphasis on designer wear and makeup makes the similarity to clueless a little bit more evident. I am not sure, if that was the case in Emma...

Shuchi:

Sonam Kapoor calls Aisha a "chick flick" [http://bit.ly/9XYEl9] - that's sent alarm bells ringing in my head. I hope the Aisha team hasn't mutilated my beloved novel Emma!

rekha:

Shilpa: Yes, you are right about the fashion part. The painting (some sketch that shows up in the promos is from emma, I dont remember if that was in clueless it probably was :) )

Vinitha:

You are right Shilpa the first promo itself reminded me of clueless.. Clueless was based on Emma so I guess this one is gonna be based on Emma n Clueless.

Rekha Santhanam:

so sounds like it is more clueless..at least from reviews..have to watch it..but now wondering if I should.

@Meetu: waiting for your review.

Shilpa:

Meetu... hope things are good at your end. tc.

lost in confusion:

Missed your reviews, meetu. Can you tell me where can I find the time at which this review (or any review on wogma, for that matter) was posted?
I'm wondering if I should cry out for the missing 'Notepad' on other's behalf b'coz I, for one, have never cared for it.

joy:

This was a good movie. Yes, no great story, but it followed the book. The characters were great, and so were the dialogs. A lot better than crap like I Hate Luv Storys, APKGK, and Love Aaj Kal.

meetu:

@lost in confusion hmmm...i intentionally kept the date stamp away. Though it was of hardly any value after the first couple days. Will look into plugging it in somewhere.

Aisha:

Love love love the movie.....

RR:

@joy [comment deleted due to personal attack on another commentor]

FFFF:

@joy:
'It followed the book'

The book on Wannabe Crap film making? or the Book on 'Looking Down on non-urban India'?

Because it certainly didn't follow 'The Book' Emma unless it was the book on it's Hollywood adaptation 'Clueless'

TimELiebe:

It's very like CLUELESS, Shilpa - though to its credit, it lets the characters grow a bit more by having some of her friends challenge her "meddling in the affairs of people less 'cool' than" her.

On the other hand, I'm not entirely sure I find Sonam Kapoor's Aisha as appealing as I did Alicia Silverstone Cher - maybe because Aisha seems even more self-absorbed than Cher did, who at least seemed to both love and care for her father and seemed less casually heartless (though maybe this is a cultural difference?). I found I liked the other characters more here - Pinky and Randhir in particular felt like sharply-observed, if not unexpected, characters revolving around Aisha's orbit.

I know this board isn't supposed to care about what goes on outside the movie itself - but even before I knew Sonam Kapoor is the daughter of International Movie Star and Producer Anil Kapoor, I'd wondered if this wasn't some kind of vanity project. It had a lot of changes of clothes and the latest toys circa last year, and while Aisha had a character arc it...well, felt like something an actor would come up with as "deep" rather than something that a good writer would devise. Thing is, it isn't a bad movie, and Regency Romance and Bollywood are a very good fit - but it feels like it should have been much better than it was.

meetu:

@TimELiebe good point about an actor's concept of "deep" vs. a writer's concept. Didn't think of it that way.

TimELiebe:

meetu - I'm a former (unsuccessful) actor turned (bit more successful) writer. I tend to think like that - to the disgust of my actor friends! ;)

meetu:

@TimELiebe aah! i see!! Anything I might have seen?

Mansi:

I had been warned about the film before I hit the theatre! "Pathetic," "drag," "awful" was what I'd heard. I was still curious to see just how pathetic it could get ;) Despite all my fangirl-ism for Sonam K, louv for Abhay D and huge expectations from the film, it did turn out 'p.' A shallow storyline with cardboard characters (save a few), Aisha will only be remembered until your next movie on the theater. The film, all swank and ritzy, is high up on the visual quotient, but that is all there is to it!
http://eatpraylovemovies.blogspot.com/2010/08/visual-delight-and-thats-it.html

Godiva :

@shilpa & @ TomEL.
Ya it's definitely like clueless. I watched Aisha today n I could tell it's so similar from the start. Like the tweed skirt & coat, fighting over remote n much more. Emma was written during 1815 or sth & author definitely didn't mention remote thingy there. Anyways, clueless is an awesome movie n the name just suits perfectly. well atleast, we've a new movie in India with nice western clothes even though that same movie existed more than a decade earlier.

TimELiebe:

meetu - as an actor, nothing you'd recognize me in. I was what Bollywood calls a "Junior Artist" - mostly extra work, voiceover, and one- or two-line parts. I was in FT. APACHE, THE BRONX, IN GOD WE TRUST, OFF BEAT, ATTACK OF THE KILLER TOMATOES, a lot of radio drama for the United States' National Public Radio, and did the opening voiceover in the cult hit SHOCK! SHOCK! SHOCK!

I wonder - have you ever read any Georgette Heyer? She was a British Regency Romance writer of the early-mid Twentieth Century, who has written a number of books that I think Bollywood could do an excellent job adapting. If you haven't, may I suggest you try reading her THE GRAND SOPHY, VENETIA, ARABELLA, FREDERICA and FALSE COLORS - and see if you don't agree they'd do very well....

meetu:

@TimELiebe Will certainly give it a shot! Though romantic stories are not really my thing :D

Leave a new comment