no gossip, no scandals

movie reviews ...and more

02 Jul 09

Via Darjeeling - Notepad

Quick Review

Rating: Catch on DVD for sure (rating scale) - extra credit for trying a rarely attempted concept
The broad concept is truly intriguing but the basic story is like a balloon losing air...*phuuussss*
This page has additional observations, other than the ones noted in the main review.

Plot Summary

A police inspector (Vinay Pathak) is investigating a case of a man gone missing (Kay Kay Menon) as reported by his wife (Sonali Kulkarni). He happens to narrate this case ia group of friends (Rajat Kapoor, Simone Singh, Sandhya Mridul, Prrosshant Narayanan). The conversation takes a few turns.

What Worked

  • The opening shot inside the car, hand held video camera effect was good and very well edited.

What did not

Note: This section simply lists the things that I did not like in this movie. This is not the overall impression about this movie. Please read the full review here
If everything is a figment of someone's imagination, you cannot really comment on things being off. Anything is possible in imagination...

Via Darjeeling - Cast and Crew

Comments(9)

Mayur:

yep, the movie looks promising, and assessing single incident with different point of views is quite a cool theme.(and simultaneously reverse folding every individual's psychological character, remember "12 angry men") It would be interesting to see something like that in this movie.

posted 1 year, 8 months ago

meetu:

hmmm..."assessing single incident with different point of views"...is that what this one is about? I love such movies. Haven't seen "suraj ka saatva ghoda" yet! :(

posted 1 year, 8 months ago

:

Via Darjeeling - Review...

The broad concept is truly intriguing but the basic story is like a balloon losing air...*phuuussss*
Idea gets lost in translation from script to screen.

Yet we need to give extra credit for going with a concept rarely tried....

posted 1 year, 8 months ago

Mayur:

well, won't keep much expectations now, ll catch it tomorrow.

posted 1 year, 8 months ago

Sudhir Nair:

// I am just kicked by how the audience is taken for a ride //

Somehow that line makes me look forward to the film. I saw the rediff review also and it made me feel there's genuinely something hatke..let's see, may catch it.

And speaking of taking audience for a ride u must watch a Spanish movie called 'Incautos' (Swindled). That movie really takes the audience for a ride and the audience loves it as well !

posted 1 year, 8 months ago

meetu:

That would be a good idea, Mayur.

That was the intention, Sudhir. The only thing I liked about the movie is how the audience was totally frustrated in the end. Good or bad, it at least had a non-numbing effect on the brain.

Both of you, do let us know what you thought of the movie.

posted 1 year, 8 months ago

Mayur:

well, well, well, keeping less expectations didn't help. What were the creators thinking while making this film, it was like "oh I got one concept, lets make a movie on that", screenplay is loose, characterization is weak, fine art of story telling is completely missing. And what is with all those defensive conversations like "yeha pe koi psychoanalyst hona chahiye tha." and concluding speech by Vinay Pathak's character. Good opportunity wasted, big disappointment.

posted 1 year, 8 months ago

agnihotra:

hey man, the char maker does no seem to understand movies... he is a cheap movie reporter..i think he shud understand movies before jumping into such conclusion..the way he has rated the movies will misguide people. he mus be changed.

posted 1 year, 8 months ago

RONNY:

"YEP THIS KIND OF MOVIES I LOVE AND VIA DARJEELING IS A VERY GOOD FILM AND THE SCRIPT WRITER HAS WRITTEN A FANTASTIC SCRIPT AND THE ACTORS HAVE DONE A FABUOLOUS WORK ESPECIALLY KAY KAY MENON

posted 1 year, 7 months ago

Leave a new comment

Ads
Recent Comments
Darshak on 'Right Yaaa Wrong'
Hi, The song "Meri Aashao Ki" is surprise in the movie... Sung by new singer ... ...more
generic apcalis sx on 'The Hurt Locker'
ZFSc6q Aloha! and albendazole without prescription and http://www.tigblog.org/group/albendazolefda/#930 albendazole without prescription and >:(( and ...more
mahek on 'Dil Bole Hadippa'
Even i think dil bole hadippa was an amazing film well everyone has different opinions ...more
OSO a gem ???? i second vishal's comment... meetu shud b back as reviewer atleast ... ...more