no gossip, no scandals.
movie reviews ... and more
wogma tip: ! ! NEW ! ! To place order for your FilmyTee, click here ! ! NEW ! !

That Girl In Yellow Boots - Wogma Readers Reviews

That Girl In Yellow Boots

wogma rating: Add to 'must watch' list (?)
quick review: That Girl In Yellow Boots is a simple story with soul about a girl who has lost hers and is desperately looking for it. Even if what she is looking for is an image of a father she's never had and always wanted. Whether or not she finds the father is as important as what she goes through to find him. The gritty nature of the film and the subject is not something all of us can handle for it takes guts to accept the truth about the society that we are a part of. It's an important film but not one I'd want to watch again.
Audio review (subscribe):
[Poster for That Girl In Yellow Boots] 7 readers have given That Girl In Yellow Boots an average rating of 4/5.0
5 yays
0 nays
2 so-so
  • So-So by Jeevan:
  • Thumbs up by Samir:
  • Thumbs up by jitaditya: Good but wanted a bit more...
  • Thumbs up by SocialDhaba: Though not for masala film lovers, ‘That Girl in Yellow Boots’ is certainly avant must watch
  • So-So by lilu: 75
  • Thumbs up by ASHOK KUMAR:
  • Thumbs up by Suman:

That Girl In Yellow Boots - Movie Details

That Girl In Yellow Boots - Trailer

If you cannot see a video above, click here to see it on YouTube

That Girl In Yellow Boots - All reviews summary

External Reviews

27 reviewers have given That Girl In Yellow Boots an average rating of 3.6/5.0. 15 yays, 3 nays, 9 so-so. See all external reviews »

Twitter Reviews

On twitter, 48 twitterers have given That Girl In Yellow Boots an average rating of 4.0/5.0. 37 yays, 9 nays, 2 so-so. See all tweets »

Readers' Ratings

7 readers have given That Girl In Yellow Boots an average rating of 4/5.0. 5 yays, 0 nays, 2 so-so. See all reader reviews »

Comments (11)

Pondy:

I am still to watch the movie, but am looking forward to watching it soon. I am guessing that the script may have not been as tight as you expected, and that was why the second best rating, which is fine.
But I disagree that the feel of the movie or the ending of the movie should really affect your rating of the movie. So, if that was the only reason for you to have downgraded the movie from 'Must watch' to 'Only the Keen..', I would suggest that you reconsider your rating.
In my view, a film review should rate a movie based on solely the film craft (though I get a hint from your review that the film craft was also lacking in some departments), and not how it makes one feel.

meetu:

@Pondy Hmmm...I disagree. A film makes me react. It is made, so that I react. And my opinion here is only my attempt to describe how I reacted and what might have caused the reaction. For me, story and how it ends is a huge part of whether or not a film works for me. I don't know how to separate that from the craft of film-making. And I'm not sure I should know how either.

Here, I liked the story and the climax was appropriate. I was unsettled by the uncomfortable feeling I had through out the film. That could be the intention of the film, but I didn't like it.

Please do watch it and let us know how you liked it.

Pondy:

@meetu, to each his own, but then I think of movies like A Clockwork Orange, Requiem for a Dream, and I can vouch for the unease factors of these movies.

Samir:

Meetu, just about everything in your review was apt. I came back after watching the film, with a sense of having experienced a small gem and was completely overwhelmed by the combination of street smartness and innocence that Kalki could imbue Ruth with. Very good filmmaking.

Jitaditya:

A good film and as usual this AK film also gives us some delightful new actors in the supporting roles....

As films with women protagonists are rare, it was a refreshing experience. Although the shock part is relative, especially for a Kashyap film, taboo topics no longer shocking.

I found Nasir's character to be a bit unconvincing. His reaction on learning what Ruth does for a living is hard to believe... as a regular customer he never guessed it??

SocialDhaba:

Mystical and determined, there is more to Ruth (Kalki Koechlin) than just Yellow Boots. She has travelled all the way to India from England in search for a man who loves her. She searches for her father in Pondicherry, in Goa and now in Mumbai mainly in pursuit of unconditional love, but there is a truth that she has to encounter, that leaves her shattered. ‘That Girl In Yellow Boots’ will stun, surprise and form an instant connection with you.

meetu:

@Pondy i have seen those films and been made extremely uncomfortable by them too, but that doesn't keep me from being made uneasy by other films. That's like saying having seen the beauty of the Himalayas, I won't be able to appreciate the monsoons in Sahyadris.

@samir thanks. :)

@Jitaditya i gave the script the benefit of doubt in that. I assumed that Naseeruddin Shah's character must have refused to take his clothes off the first time and thus never been asked teh regular question by Ruth.

lilu:

Terrific film. Worth the time. The ending did not shock me, it was kind of expected, but overall this is a brilliant effort given the small budget and resources employed. Would like to see Kashyap do a big budget no holds barred entertainer with a soul. He must challenge himself. He needs to be seen by more people and he needs to grow as a filmmaker. More power to him and his team.

meetu:

@Lilu now that would be fun, no? Anurag Kashyap doing his thing with a mainstream subject/story.

ASHOK KUMAR:

ANURAAG, AFTER HIS MASTERPIECE, DEV D, HAS GIVEN THE DISCERNING FILM VIEWERS YET ANOTHER RAREST FILM. THE FILM GRAPHICALLY DEPICTS THE HARROWING LIFE OF SINGLE WORKING WOMEN IN URBAN INDIA. ONLY A DIRECTOR OF ANURAAG'S EMINENCE CAN TOUCH UPON A SUBJECT LIKE THE UGLIEST AND DEMONIC FACE OF SEX IN THE MOST APPROPRIATE CINEMATIC LANGUAGE. KALKI TAKES THE AUDIENCE DEEP INTO THE HEART AND SOUL OF THE CHARACTER SHE HAS PORTRAYED WITH HER STERLING PERFORMANCE. THE FILM LEAVES A EVERLASTING IMPACT ON THE VIEWERS MIND. PRODUCERS OF BOLLYWOOD, INSTEAD OF PROVIDING THE USUAL SONG AND DANCE MOVIES, SHOULD ENCOURAGE ANURAAG TO DIRECT SUCH FILMS TO EXPOSE THE GROWING ROT AND FILTH IN THE SOCIETY. LET MORE SUCH SOCIALLY CORRECTIVE AND MEANINGFUL CINEMAS COME FROM THE MAVERICK DIRECTOR ANURAAG IN THE COMING YEARS------ASHOK KUMAR

Suman:

Direction: 3.5
Story: 3
Lead Actors: 3.5
Character Artists: 3.5

Dialogues: 3
Screenplay: 3
Music Director: 1
Lyrics: 2

Leave a new comment